News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by dang on Sunday January 06, 2019 @01:34AM (#18836932)
Please don't post unsubstantive comments, especially not flamebait, and especially not racewar flamebait, to Hacker News. We ban accounts that do that, because they produce lame and acrid discussions that we don't want here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by mshron on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:25PM (#18835400)
Respectfully, I think you're working from an outdated definition of racism and sexism.

People have already been treated differently on the basis of their race and sex for their entire lives. Starting at the end, and assuming that being colorblind will solve the problem (which has been basically the official policy in our society for the last 40 years), empirically hasn't worked out that well.

Instead, we should be taking active measures to improve opportunities, including examining how to make our companies more welcoming places to be, as per the OP:

> Sometimes the interventions are much more work: creating a company culture that is not hostile for black women.

> But the net result is the same: more inclusion, better talent, and a better end product.

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by OCASM on Saturday January 05, 2019 @08:50PM (#18835824)
"In order to end racism and sexism we have to be racist and sexist."

No, all you end up with is more sexism and racism.

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by yowlingcat on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:02PM (#18835272)
You're getting downvoted for this because you've painted with an awfully broad brush. I think there's a lot of good work that D&I policies _can_ theoretically do. But in practice? I've seen them implemented by folks that don't really have the creativity or charisma or gravitas to pull it off because make no mistake, it's challenging, risky, failure prone work. I'm going to keep an open mind to seeing it possibly work, but I haven't really seen it at this point. I don't think it's for ill will -- rather, I think it's simply very, very hard to pull off. I think the devil is in the details.

Let me go to bat for you -- it's possible that D&I policies can actually be used at face value to reproduce the very same systems they sought to eradicate, where folks are selected for positions of power that they fail at simply because of something external to their physical identity. And more to the point, I think it's a little naive and hubristic to believe that you can bureaucratize the problems of bigotry away. Such attempts may create surface level effects, but will fail to address the roots of the problem, which will probably just adopt another more cautious disguise and continue onward.

What's the solution, then? Sadly, I don't think there is an easy one. I am inclined to say the solution is creative destruction. We as an industry and society must move forward as a whole, and show how much more effectively diverse, well run companies can perform if we truly believe it's a superior manner of organizing firms. The presumptions, assumptions, blind spots and biases that cause these problems to occur must simply disappear through the process of that; if they don't, then perhaps it would signal to us that something else is going on.

I may be a bit cynical, but that is exactly what I expect to happen. Human beings are cliquey, tribal creatures. Many will be awful to themselves, their close friends and their family, never mind the coworkers that they actually like. When faced with the sheer difficulty and significance of adequate managing and mentoring employees to help mature, how am I supposed to believe that diversity and inclusion are anything but subsections of that greater whole? In the engineering world, what would a shallow, presumptuous thinker be but a junior employee that needs to grow in order to be trusted with more responsibility? I think D&I needs to be looked at through this pragmatic lens rather than the moralistic, sensationalistic and bureaucratic/disciplinarian lens that it is so often seen through. And sadly, this level of creativity and systems design is outside the amount (and seemingly the capability) of many (but not all) who are tasked with it.

The best way to deal with these problems, rather, is to avoid them in the first place. So long as we live in a world where unfair areas exist, leaders that proactively create ideologically, culturally and physically diverse firms, and instill cultures where racism, sexism and all forms of discrimination are not part of the organizational DNA will thrive over those that attempt (usually in vain) to retrofit it. I think this is the only way forward that I can see. And I do agree with you that treating a person differently based on their race or sex either positively or negatively is ultimately ineffective. The former is patronizing, the latter is oppressing. We deserve better.

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by HillaryBriss on Saturday January 05, 2019 @08:04PM (#18835582)
> how much more effectively diverse, well run companies can perform if we truly believe it's a superior manner of organizing firms

or even if it isn't. one can make the case that D&I is the top-tier, number one priority even if it reduces corporate efficiency, competitiveness, or profitability

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by chillacy on Sunday January 06, 2019 @02:56AM (#18837190)
That’ll only work if everyone does it, otherwise your competition will drive you out of business. And that includes companies form other countries which may not even have those issues.
Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by HillaryBriss on Sunday January 06, 2019 @12:49PM (#18839489)
That is why there are federal laws.

I mean look at a history in the US of federal housing anti discrimination laws. A whole raft of laws have been in effect for the last 50 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employment_discrimination_law_...

There are still a large number of businesses in operation.

Plus, look at it from society's point of view. If we have a situation where corporations are profiting but employment opportunities are unfairly distributed, various political groups in a free society will form to try and change the laws until corporations change their behavior. There will be agitation and unrest. If that goes on long enough, we may end up in a situation where the society, the economy, the government deteriorate.

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by cybersol on Saturday January 05, 2019 @10:28PM (#18836378)
Sure in an ideal world you would not need affirmative action or whatever they want to call it these days. Also in a perfect utopia communism lets everyone share everything equally and is clearly superior to capitalism. Unfortunately we don't live in perfect utopia, and thus need practical solutions like capitalism, democracy, and even affirmative action. Which reminds me of Churchill's quote: "Democracy is the worst form of Government except all those other forms that have been tried..."
Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by mbrumlow on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:45PM (#18835172)
No. But people like this speaking in the way he did can be a step in the right direction.

Most pundents of D&I have their ass so far up their head they don't realize that they fail at D&I because the only reconize a 3rd grade level of what that means.

This guy at least from the single post I have read -- seems to get it, and get it in a way that might actually spark real change.

[dead]
Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by fzeroracer on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:12PM (#18835318)
>Unfortunately, most D&I efforts appear to be “push non white, non male candidates to the front of the pipeline”. No amount of window dressing fixes D&I efforts that are sexist or racist.

This is just objectively wrong. The goal of D&I efforts is that non-white and non-male candidates already suffer from less opportunity than similarly talented white male candidates. Whenever you argue for a reset to 'equality of opportunity', you're arguing for a return to even less opportunity for minority candidates.

In order to fix this problem, you first have to recognize that equality of opportunity does not exist. D&I efforts are a bandaid fix while new generations hopefully don't face as much racism or lack of opportunity.

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:13PM (#18835331)
If you’re doing anything other than blind interviews and stripping personal info off of resumes, you’re discriminating, regardless of your objectives. The road to hell needs no further paving.

I encourage those who witness or are impacted by D&I activities that violate labor law to report them to regulators, and even an employment attorney, whenever possible.

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by fzeroracer on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:21PM (#18835382)
Blind interviews do not help like you think [1] and overall the fact of the matter is that it's just not proven to work yet.

It sounds like you're making up a lot of hysteria for absolutely nothing, considering I have rarely seen any D&I efforts that would negatively impact me as a white man. Ultimately if you want to argue about D&I efforts being ineffectual you need to be less sensationalist and more grounded in facts.

[1] http://behaviouraleconomics.pmc.gov.au/projects/going-blind-...

Re:Talent Is Everywhere, Opportunity Is Not by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:29PM (#18835419)
I don’t think I’m being sensationalist, generating hysteria, nor am I asking to discuss this with you. I made my comments primarily so that those with grievances about D&I activities in their orgs that don’t adhere to labor law have an idea how to seek redress. No more, no less.

Edit: continuing to argue here is simply going to pollute the thread and risks a mod detachment. My email is in my profile if you want to continue the discussion.