If someone wants to represent the 'average' programmer then the best way to do it would be to educate themselves on the language and the current state of standardization and then participate as an advocate for those programmers.
It seems that the people who are supposed to be speaking for the regular programmers aren't doing a particularly good job.
I agree with this. The people at CppCon are very smart, very informed, and very very pro-C++. It's silly to think that such a person (people on the committee, no less), would be a good spokesperson for your everyday programmer.
However, that's certainly not the main problem keeping C++ complexity high. Even though the committee genuinely wants improvement in this area, there is too much fear of breaking legacy code, and too many early design mistakes to overcome on the path back to a simpler C++.
I'm not personally that interested in making it my mission to help educate people who don't want to be educated but perhaps it would be a valuable way for someone to get involved. People complaining on the basis of wrong information or misunderstandings aren't likely to be taken terribly seriously though.
I'm not part of the standards committee nor do I represent the C++ community as a whole. I personally am not particularly interested in trying to educate people who don't want to be educated. That doesn't say anything about whether I or anyone else in the C++ community is interested in the opinions of regular C++ programmers.
I also note that you yourself are perfectly willing to complain about things in areas where you lack an in-depth understanding:
- Papers "written in a way that's deliberately inaccessible"
- "I'd be marginalized for not using template metaprogramming" - a major topic is how to get the benefits of template metaprogramming techniques without the ugly syntax that everyone dislikes.
- "I'd be marginalized for ... not knowing the new hotness by heart" - a major purpose of CppCon talks is to explain the new hotness.
- "it's led by academics who think the concerns of working programmers like me are beneath them" - the majority of speakers at CppCon and members of the standards committee are working programmers, not academics and none of them show any evidence of thinking the concerns of working programmers are beneath them, quite the opposite in fact.
And unicode is still insanely complex.
It's particularly discouraging to see you use someone's understandable nervousness about attending a conference as a basis to attack them for their "ignorance". Ironically, that just confirms that arandr0x is right to be a little nervous!
If you transpose your attitudes to the complexity of C++ and the complexity of unicode (“you suck because you don’t understand C++” vs. “unicode sucks because I don’t understand it”), then you might see what arandr0x is getting at.
In a way it isn't fair. Most users of most programming languages don't know the language very well. So the views of these programmers are important.