News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Android development income report by watty on Monday November 08, 2010 @09:03AM (#1882481)
Some HN users motivation for side projects is to impress other HN users, "make something really impressive". Others are trying to make money and this is how Kreci succeeded (a la Notch).
Re:My Android development income report by cma on Monday November 08, 2010 @08:08PM (#1884835)
I don't think those are the only two possible motivations.

"Nor could he ever wean himself from the notion, which is perhaps especially an American notion, that success and virtue are the same thing."

Re:My Android development income report by jacquesm on Monday November 08, 2010 @09:06AM (#1882488)
Let me reword that to 'useful' instead of impressive.
Re:My Android development income report by maxklein on Monday November 08, 2010 @09:10AM (#1882499)
Who defines what is 'useful'? I have a cousin, he sits at home all day, watching TV. When he buys apps, he does not want or care for things like 'currency bot'. Why would he care about that, he never needs to convert currency. But if he sees something like the x-ray stuff, he'd be quite entertained by it.

For him, it's much more useful than a VIM clone for android. Your definition of useful is not the same as most of the worlds definition.

Re:My Android development income report by CrazedGeek on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:06AM (#1882641)
use·ful

1. being of use or service; serving some purpose; advantageous, helpful, or of good effect: a useful member of society.

2. of practical use, as for doing work; producing material results; supplying common needs: the useful arts; useful work.

Seems to me that his definition is spot on.

Re:My Android development income report by steveklabnik on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:16AM (#1882667)
The point maxklein was making is that these apps are useful to someone, otherwise, kreci wouldn't be making money from them.

Just because we don't deem them useful here doesn't mean there aren't people who do find them useful.

Re:My Android development income report by exit on Monday November 08, 2010 @01:25PM (#1883363)
> ... these apps are useful to someone, otherwise, kreci wouldn't be making money from them.

this logic only works out if you approach things myopically.

do you think drug dealers provide a useful commodity? they're certainly making a lot of money.

the apps described take advantage of some neurological disposition to gimmicks / novelty - it's not a given that the world is a better place because of them.

Re:My Android development income report by steveklabnik on Monday November 08, 2010 @01:42PM (#1883433)
I guess you're calling capitalism myopic. I don't necessarily disagree with you, but that's the framework we've set up.

(And yes, I do think drug dealers provide value. It's a service, people want it. In any other context, we'd be writing articles about how a perceptive entrepreneur rose up from a simple upbringing to rolling in cash, it's just that we look down upon the product.)

There's a pretty decent sibling of mine who's dead. You may want to turn showdead on temporarily.

Re:My Android development income report by exit on Monday November 08, 2010 @02:37PM (#1883666)
yes, capitalism is myopic and you can justify many myopic conclusions by limiting yourself to its framework.

> ... it's just that we look down upon the product.

that's an amusing misdirection. it's actually more about the lives ruined and suffering experienced by way of the product.

> What is your definition of wealth? Paul Graham says, and I tend to agree with him, that wealth is "things people want". If people want these apps (or drugs), then the apps (and drugs) create wealth.

wealth is control over other people. having lots of money in a capitalist system is a proxy for being able to control lots of other people in this system.

taking advantage of neurological hooks (chemical in the case of drugs, or sensual in the case of advertising / apps / etc) is certainly one way to gain controller over others (by the proxy of money).

i suppose if your concerns are entirely contained within the bounds of playing that game (very much the case for many entrepreneurial types) there's no motivation to challenge its definition of "value".

Re:My Android development income report by steveklabnik on Monday November 08, 2010 @02:48PM (#1883712)
> it's actually more about the lives ruined and suffering experienced by way of the product.

This is an 'amusing misdirection,' to use your own words, about you forcing your own morality on others. There are plenty of people that use drugs without ruining their lives, no need to get high and mighty about it.

> wealth is control over other people.

Hey man, I'm an anarchist. I understand exactly what you're saying. But regardless of my own personal thoughts on the subject, that's not the way that this country is set up.

As I said over here[1], it's just that we're talking about two different things. Within capitalism, kreci is creating value. If you'd like to discuss a different system, then you need to tell everyone that you're talking about something else. When on a forum about startups, I assume people are discussing the current system by default.

1: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1882865

Re:My Android development income report by andreyf on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:58AM (#1882815)
You can't be serious. Just because people are willing to pay money for it doesn't mean it's worth your time. There's nothing wrong with making money on the side with a couple of apps like this, but just as AIDS or cancer research is more "useful" than penis pills or breast enhancement surgery regardless of profitability, there are many ways for mobile developers to "push the state of the art" without making more fake cracked screen apps.
Re:My Android development income report by steveklabnik on Monday November 08, 2010 @11:12AM (#1882865)
> Just because people are willing to pay money for it doesn't mean it's worth your time.

By definition, if someone is willing to pay money for something, it's worth _their_ time, which is the whole point of making products.

We preach "Making something that a customer finds valuable. MVP and iterate. Get lots of feedback to build something the customer wants." So kreci builds something people want.

> ust as AIDS or cancer research is more "useful" than penis pills or breast enhancement surgery regardless of profitability

This is where the main discrepancy comes in. You guys are talking about two different things: 'value' within a capitalist framework and 'nobility' within your particular moral one. Neither one is necessarily 'better', but that's the core difference.

Re:My Android development income report by Yzupnick on Monday November 08, 2010 @12:06PM (#1883089)
> This is where the main discrepancy comes in. You guys are talking about two different things: 'value' within a capitalist framework and 'nobility' within your particular moral one. Neither one is necessarily 'better', but that's the core difference.

I think this is something that is confused all the time, even by people who realize the distinction. It is something I (and I suspect others) find hard to keep track of without actively thinking about it.

Re:My Android development income report by steveklabnik on Monday November 08, 2010 @12:17PM (#1883127)
Absolutely. I think it's a common trap that we all fall into; I know that I do, for sure. We assume that something doesn't have any value unless it solves a hard problem. In reality, there's a ton of low-hanging fruit out there just waiting to be exploited.

As the web matures, I think we'll look back and realize that this is an era where the problem space looks like a tree: a trunk has sprung up of problems that we're solving, and then we're going to the highest levels of difficulty, branching out. Eventually, more will start doing what some people (like kreci) are just starting to do: working on easier problems. There's a whole world out there of things that we can easily be doing to help people with their day. They may not be 'noble', but even fart apps have their place in people's lives.

Numerous fortunes have been made from pornography, professional wrestling, and soap operas. We'd do well to remember that.

Re:My Android development income report by stonemetal on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:02PM (#1885110)
You missed the part where he isn't asking for money so people are not paying money for these apps.
Re:My Android development income report by parfe on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:39AM (#1882745)
I've never seen you comment on someone else's success without coming across as bitter.
Re:My Android development income report by jacquesm on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:45AM (#1882769)
> I've never seen you comment on someone else's success without coming across as bitter.

Is that so?

Wow.

References please, and don't pull your punches. Then, for an encore go search for those cases where I've done my utmost to get HN'ers stuff launched and helped them with goods, time, funds, traffic and whatever else I've got to give.

What would you rather have, my unvarnished opinion or do you think it would be helpful if I fawned over what I essentially perceive to be a bunch of fart apps?

Re:My Android development income report by parfe on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @06:43PM (#1888465)
I think the fact that my post dipped as low as -4 before bouncing back up to +1 in a 24 hour period shows I'm not the only one who holds such an opinion. I see no need to go trawling through your posting history.