Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by rdl on Monday November 08, 2010 @07:29AM
(#1882236)
For me it is a lot more specific. I wouldn't have a big problem with enhanced interrogation in some contexts (I think torture is a bad policy and a losing strategy for a country, but in a classified interrogation context, wouldn't rock the boat). I have certainly been around recreational bdsm scenes which were fairly intense as well. I just don't trust doctors (psychologists, MDs) to be competent -- I have seen too many fuckups. Plus, there would be little personal risk in standing up to them.
In the ww2 context, I am kind of ashamed to say I would have been an amoral defense contractor, doing whatever made me the most money with access to the best technical challenges and toys. I wouldn't have been initially willing to start off with war crimes, but I could definitely see using slave labor, overlooking virtually any other crimes, to ship, especially if it seemed like losing could lose the war. Or, if not a defense industrialist, a soldier.
You and 99% of all people hearing about the Milgram experiments. The essential point, however, is that in fact you wouldn't.
Just like 80% of all people state they'd DEFINITELY have been in the resistance during Third Reich. It's convenient to say that, but statistics tell us otherwise.