Ad hominem isn't a good look, nor an effective argument when it comes to policy. Too often I see dismissals based on indirect associations with the Koch brothers or unsubstantiated allegations of white nationalism. I don't see how ad hominem by progressives is any better than someone dismissing research data because of "links" to think tanks funded by George Soros, etc.
Re:Seattle’s Homeless Challenge
by longerthoughts on Thursday January 03, 2019 @08:08PM
(#18821116)
>I don't see how ad hominem by progressives is any better than someone dismissing research data because of "links" to think tanks funded by George Soros, etc.
Are you saying association with a partisan think tank is equally as damning as association with white nationalism?
It's an issue of morality. Being morally bankrupt should probably challenge somebody's credibility more than having stances on policy that some don't agree with.
Please read my comment closely. I said neither are "damning", because ad hominem shouldn't be considered a reason to "damn" ideas in an unrelated policy debate. Especially unsubstantiated allegations about a second or third degree connection.
Re:Seattle’s Homeless Challenge
by longerthoughts on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:56PM
(#18829154)
I agree that ad hominem attacks are overwhelmingly used to evade the responsibility of substantive debate. The problem is that policy debates are not purely objective and in reality people weigh presented perspectives and evidence according to the perceived credibility of a given source. As a result, information that speaks to the soundness of a person's judgement has a place in policy debate as a means of drawing conclusions in the absence of indisputable facts.
We're all placing faith in something that determines what we call truth and what we call lies or ignorance.
Re:Seattle’s Homeless Challenge
by fzeroracer on Friday January 04, 2019 @06:17PM
(#18828674)
I have more than substantiated my allegations and I would easily argue this goes beyond a second or third degree connection.
Moral bankruptcy isn't necessarily transitive.
How many degrees of separation from a white nationalist must one be in order to be moral?
Re:Seattle’s Homeless Challenge
by longerthoughts on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:25PM
(#18829027)
I would argue that it is transitive but diminishes in proportion to the degrees of separation and depends upon both awareness and the nature of the association. For example, discounting somebody's moral standing for knowingly befriending a pedophile seems more reasonable than discounting their moral standing because their cousin unknowingly befriended a pedophile.
Re:Seattle’s Homeless Challenge
by fzeroracer on Thursday January 03, 2019 @08:32PM
(#18821228)
I think that says a lot more about you than anything else, considering we've seen a large surge in white nationalist activity over the past year. We should be very concerned, especially when they're becoming violent and lashing out at people like the Proud Boys.
Re:Seattle’s Homeless Challenge
by AnimalMuppet on Thursday January 03, 2019 @08:39PM
(#18821260)
We should beware white nationalism. It's real, and it's a problem. We should also beware playing six-degrees-of-white-nationalism. You could probably tar everyone with that brush, including Obama, me, and fzeroracer.
It's gotten to the point that I don't trust these vague-links-to-white-nationalism accusations at all. They so rarely have any substance to them that they make me more suspicious of the person accusing than the person being accused.