So I think this is where the disagreement happens. You are following the laws of physics, but I wouldn't say that you're not conscious. Notably, we're talking about "consciousness" and not "free will", which is what I think you're actually arguing against for the electron.
If you extend the definition of conscious for humans (whatever it means) to an extended definition that includes electrons, and the extended definition of conscious electron is "they just follow the (current) laws of physics", then the extended definition is meaningless. Everything is conscious in it's own way, and this doesn't give a cue about what human consciousness is.
For a similar fuzzy defined term, let's pick "alive". Humans are alive (when they are not dead). Electrons are not alive. There is an arbitrary threshold in the middle, but the current guess is that there is no magical part in being alive. From electrons to humans, we all follow the laws of Physics.
You can redefine alive, so an electron is alive by following the (current) laws of Physics. But now being alive is a meaningless term, because everything is alive in its own way.
If we agree that "alive" simply arises from ever more complicated chemical processes, and that we've specified an arbitrary line somewhere to give the term meaning, then that's fine. But it no longer makes sense to ask questions like "why are we alive?" or "at what point does something go from being just chemistry to being alive?". Because these answers are implicit in the definition itself. Yes, "alive" still has meaning but these questions don't have meaningful answers.
Now in the case of "consciousness", I think that it might be much the same way. I think we've overloaded and conflated the term with different concepts which gives rise to resistance. Let's call the supposed fundamental property "experience" instead, and say that this is what the electron has. Then your "human consciousness" becomes what arises from that "experience" property overlayed onto your body as a chemical system.
And this might seem useless, but I think it's not. The main mystery, which is "how am I here experiencing this?" Is answered by: this "experience", which seems so special to us and we assume we're the only ones that have it, is just the default of everything in the universe, and the subjective part of it is in the systems where the particular experience manifests. So with this view, the question: "what gives me consciousness but not an ant?" Reduces to the same arbitrary distinction like we've said for being "alive": it's just your arbitrary definition of it, and these questions might not have any deeper answers. And I think this perspective is counterintuitive for a lot of people and that's what leads to the intense belief that the questions must have meaningful answers, because we think we're the only stuff in the universe with "experience".
For me, once I get a sense for what goes into that "experience", of being there and feeling like something inside my head, I don't have much mystery in the other stuff. For instance, I'm not concerned about equating "consciousness" to: "I think therefore I am" that's just my "experience" overlayed onto the circuitry of my brain. And I find that I disagree with Descartes. "I am" even if I can't "think", I just wouldn't be able to self-reflect about it, and those are different things.
> According to the definition of consciousness that is dominant in contemporary analytic philosophy, something is conscious just in case there is something that it’s like to be it; that is to say, if it has some kind of experience, no matter how basic. Humans have incredibly rich and complex experience, horses less so, mice less so again. Standardly the panexperientialist holds that this diminishing of the complexity of experience continues down through plants, and through to the basic constituents of reality, perhaps electrons and quarks. If the notion of “having experience” is flexible enough, then the view that an electron has experience—of some extremely basic kind—would seem to be coherent (of course we must distinguish the question of whether it is coherent from the question of whether it is plausible; the latter will depend on the strength of the arguments discussed below).
If electrons are conscious, then they must experiment some kind of change that is related to the consciousness. One possibility is that they are conscious but they don't change at all, but then why don't just say that they are not conscious, because it would be totally equivalent. Another possibility is that the consciousness of the electrons is just following the usual laws of physics, but also it would be equivalent to have non conscious electrons. So, the interesting case is when the consciousness of the electron can affect the electron somehow. So the electron must have at least two secret states (or more) and the conscious experience must make the electron change between these states.
The rules of Quantum Mechanics for collisions say that when a particle has many states, then in the debris after the collision you must consider all of them. When the state doesn't affect the forces involved in the collisions it's simple because you multiply by the number of states. For example, quarks have 3 colors, so the probability of getting a quark after a collision is 3 times bigger than the expected probability in a universe where color doesn't exist. [The actual calculations are more complicated, because you can't multiply some probabilities of the fake colorless universe by 3 and expect that the total sum of all the probabilities is still one. And you must also sometimes consider interference too. There are many technical details here, but the idea is that somewhere in the calculations you must put some 3 here and there, or the result will be wrong.]
Electrons don't have color, but they have spin. An electron can have spin "up" or "down". If there are no strong magnetic fields, the 2 version of the electron are equivalent. So in the calculations you must put a few 2 here and there to get the correct result. [If there is a strong magnetic field, or the electron is moving too fast, or you consider the weak force the two versions are not equivalent, but for the sake of simplicity let's assume boring electrons.] [The quarks have spin too, so in the calculation you must put a 3 in some places and a 2 in other places, and there are a few more details that it's better to forget to simplify the discussion.]
So... if the electrons have some additional hidden states, then by the rules of quantum mechanics you must remember to consider the secret states. In the simple case it's just a multiplication. In more complicated cases, perhaps the altered state of the electron is more heavy and the calculation is more complicated. The author says that since we haven't seen this secret state in a high energy particle accelerator, it unbelievable that it may be relevant inside your brain that. Other possibility is that the hidden state is different of the other quantum states and doesn't appear in the calculations, but I think that this possibility is too magical.
--
As a simplified version, be can consider the Pauli exclusion principle that says that in any orbital you can have up to 2 electrons. It's the same number 2 of the other paragraph. You can put in the orbital one electron with spin "up" and one electron with spin "down", and with a few simplifications both electrons are equivalent. The interesting part is that this rule was discovered experimentally, but later it was deduced from the rules of quantum mechanics. So instead of a complicated calculation [that I only can do partially, and I don't remember the details now, so I need a week or two to find the books and look at the details] ... so instead of a complicated calculation you can count how many electrons you can put in an orbital. This is very easy, you get some hot Lithium vapor in a vacuum tube and some sparks, and you can measure the energy of the third electron. In the experiment you get the first two electrons in the lower orbital, and the third electron in the next orbital. All the Chemistry is based on these kind of facts, so the Pauli exclusion principle is very well proven experimentally.
And the problem is that in the Pauli exclusion principle you get a 2, that is due to the spin. You don't have room for secret states that may be affected by the conscious experience of the electron.