News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electrons don’t think by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday January 03, 2019 @02:32PM (#18818390)
I think she's perfectly scientific.

She's also clueless about philosophy and metaphysics - which is unfortunately not that unusual among contemporary scientists.

And I don't mean philosophy in the sense of being able to debate the fine points of anything much - but in the sense of having the breadth of conceptual education to understand what's required of genuinely a rational and consistent argument, and what's actually an irrational and irrelevant appeal to authority, as this "argument" is.

This isn't particularly about panpsychism or consciousness. It's that the quality of the argument being presented is so poor.

She's drawing an identity between a taxonomy of observed behaviour and independent consciousness, and saying that any entities that can be fitted into a taxonomy can be conscious.

Which is "not even wrong."

You could just as well argue that electrons are conscious because they can read our minds while we do experiments and are trolling us by creating some made-up rules they've invented which happen to look like quantum theory.

Both make as much sense, and both are equally unhelpful as rational arguments.

Re:Electrons don’t think by skh on Thursday January 03, 2019 @04:21PM (#18819402)
You could just as well argue that electrons are conscious because they can read our minds while we do experiments and are trolling us by creating some made-up rules they've invented which happen to look like quantum theory.

One can argue similarly to give a possible explanation for anything. It's not a question of whether it could be this way but rather what seems to be the most plausible explanation. The argument you gave above (I know it's not one you are seriously purporting) seems much less likely to be correct than the one Sabine gave.

My reading of Sabine's argument is that we get the random behavior from particle collisions you expect if quantum mechanics is correct and thus electrons aren't conscious. The particles follow randomness and not what one would think would occur if there was consciousness/free will involved. Yes, she seems to make the connection between the two concepts.

I don't know if Sabine is correct but I certainly don't think

Both make as much sense, and both are equally unhelpful as rational arguments.

Re:Electrons don’t think by SiempreViernes on Thursday January 03, 2019 @02:49PM (#18818573)
Hossenfelder is speaking about the type of consciousness she herself posses, while in your argument you are talking of such consciousness as Batman might have.

Is this the underlying misunderstanding?