News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by hanniabu on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:30PM (#18812333)
The miners can choose to fork fork away from those changes. The core team is merely starting the change and the miners are supporting and carrying out those changes by continuing to mine the chain with those updates.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by exo762 on Thursday January 03, 2019 @03:26AM (#18813654)
Wrong. Economic majority decides which fork will live and which fork will die. Miners have no say. If they are unhappy, they may attempt to attack fork abiding to new rules. Whey have three venues of attack.

1. Producing blocks that abide to old rules will do nothing - client software will just reject them as incorrect. Fork choice rule (e.g. longest chain or most work done) applies when choosing between two valid blocks, not between valid block and invalid block.

2. Attempts to do a famous 51% attack is crazy expensive and have low impact. Why low impact? Because small events that are similar to rewriting history 51% attack does happen all the time. They are called block reorgs and all the software which uses blockchain as a data store have to handle it properly. Also, such attack will be perceived by users as attack on them, solidifying community around opposition to miners.

3. Targeting difficulty adjustment algorithm by mining on a fork and leaving it at the beginning of adjustment period. Lets imagine 80% of miners leaving. For Bitcoin it would create a situation when adjustment period would last 8 weeks instead of 2. Blocks would be produced every 40 minutes at average instead of 10. Ethereum is immune to this type of attack since difficulty adjustment is done every block, not every 2016 blocks.

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by iSnow on Thursday January 03, 2019 @05:21AM (#18814116)
There's additionally 4. Targeting transaction throughput via spam/dust attacks where malicious miners introduce empty blocks or transactions with very small sums to clog up the network/drive up tx fees. To my knowledge, this has been tried against BTC, ETH, NEO, and BCH, where at least the dust attacks against BTC were done to try to force a big-block agenda.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by hanniabu on Thursday January 03, 2019 @10:24AM (#18815732)
All of the things you listed are in the miners control. Of course this requires economic means, but just having economic right is not enough, you still need to contribute to mining.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by exo762 on Thursday January 03, 2019 @05:04PM (#18819767)
> All of the things you listed are in the miners control.

May I ask you to elaborate? My point is - miners' power over the network is extremely limited. They are just a paid work force, working on a very small margin. They have almost no say where network will go in terms of evolution.

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by amasad on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:33PM (#18812346)
Why would the miners agree to adding the "difficulty bomb" which is against their incentives? It's more likely they didn't have a say in it.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by nostrademons on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:44PM (#18812397)
Because otherwise they end up mining the chain that nobody's using. You can own a lot of ETC and it doesn't do you much good if you can't sell them because nobody's interested in using or trading them.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by amasad on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:48PM (#18812411)
However in Bitcoin the opposite happened -- the classic chain is the most valuable one despite being the least "scalable" or whatever pet feature the forks has. Also despite all the bitcoin celebrities being for the fork. That's behaving more like a decentralized technology that no single entity controls.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by darawk on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @10:16PM (#18812547)
What's happening is people are voting with their feet. Anyone can make any fork they like, and then everyone on the network can choose which one they prefer to use. That is what decentralization means. And both Ethereum and Bitcoin have that property.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by iSnow on Thursday January 03, 2019 @05:06AM (#18814063)
A lot of BTC celebs didn't follow BCH at all. And essentially, L2 scaling as well as SegWit was shoved down our throats by the BTC Core devs. I don't see how that was very decentralized.

OTOH, I am not strongly against it, as decentralization doesn't mean every single aspect has to be free of centralized decision making (starting with the name, logo or the code). In the end, users decide if they want to use it or not.

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by chowells on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:46PM (#18812403)
If the miners ever have a serious disagreement with the core developers, they can always remove the difficulty bomb in a fork. The purpose of the difficulty bomb is to force some update, not to force the core developers' preferred update.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by make3 on Thursday January 03, 2019 @12:08AM (#18812957)
the idea that forks are easy enough for the power to be distributed seems ludacris. you need to fork a large ratio of the users in order for a fork to do anything at all, otherwise the new coin has no value. This a gives massive inertia advantage to the original project
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by SlowRobotAhead on Thursday January 03, 2019 @12:30AM (#18813046)
Thanks, I feel like I’m the crazy one when people talk about “just fork it” in response to the fact that developers of any specific coin could crash it at any point. That’s not how it works in reality.

Bitcoin could be entirely ruined by a couple dozen people around the world in different ways at any time. Eth and other coins even more so.

The idea of who “gets trusted” in these coins is just nuts. I’m not anti-coin... but man, I’m feel like I’m far enough from it to see a reality that many want to ignore.

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by iSnow on Thursday January 03, 2019 @05:12AM (#18814082)
I think your misunderstanding is believing users are locked into a crypto system if its implementation is controlled by a small group. They are not - if the developers abuse their power, users are free to migrate elsewhere and take their funds with them (in fiat value or as a different coin).

That's different to e.g. PayPal where your funds can be locked and there's nothing you can do.

Decentralized control over name, logo, features or code of a crypto coin is extremely hard to impossible, if only because there aren't too many people alive that can discuss core crypto features with any meaningful knowledge (I know I can't). Some coins do have governance features, but none of those have profited very much from that.

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by snapdangle on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:02AM (#18822779)
I believe the point being made is that the _value_ of the crypto system is largely controlled by small groups. Forks rarely achieve the value and status of the prior coin (considering ETC the "fork" here as it was the chain that didn't have the core dev approval).

Furthermore, crypto value is beholden on whales not to just dumping their vast hoards of coins into marketplaces all at once. That is to say, the largest stakeholders in a chain have the opportunity to crush the value of that chain, which means that they have power over other users' choice of chain .

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by SlowRobotAhead on Friday January 04, 2019 @10:47AM (#18824799)
That’s exactly right. And as to whales and who controls the largest amounts of coin. I think people are absolutely crazy if they think and coin since bitcoin doesn’t have the largest share holders as the devs themselves. It’s obvious why there are a million coins right now.

Itslired by the great mystery of bitcoin, it’s like an appealing urban legend to say “we don’t know who owns all our coin by design! wink”. So this doubly makes the coin devs more powerful than “but it’s decentralized” people want to admit.

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by chowells on Thursday January 03, 2019 @11:47AM (#18816492)
That's generally a good complaint about "just fork it", but there are some additional factors here.

One - every Ethereum update is a soft fork of the protocol

Two - they are required to be soft forks by the very existence of the difficulty bomb.

Three - running a blockchain is already a social activity that requires everyone participating to opt in to the same protocol.

I don't think it would be easy, by any means, to convince the community to move a different direction than that desired by the core devs. But my main point is that the difficulty bomb is a mechanism to force soft forks frequently. It is not a mechanism to force any particular long term path.

Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by DennisP on Thursday January 03, 2019 @06:56AM (#18814468)
That's a problem for the original developers as well, and is precisely why the difficulty bomb exists. It causes the original project to gradually stop working, forcing the users to migrate to newer code.
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by ascendantlogic on Thursday January 03, 2019 @12:26AM (#18813025)
Yes because humans are still the end users here and humans congregate into groups. Network effect is a human trait. In order for any network to be useful it needs a majority of people agreeing to use it, and to that end it ends up with inertia. There is no utopia, there's just "more decentralized" or "less decentralized"
Re:Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent by dahdum on Thursday January 03, 2019 @12:11AM (#18812964)
The miners aren’t looked at the same way in Ethereum because you don’t have the large concentration of mining to a handful of companies like Bitcoin.

Also because from the very first whitepaper it’s been known Ethereum would move to PoS.