This one restaurant can't employ more than a tiny fraction of paraplegics, so I doubt that will happen. Sure, irrational people could use that argument, but irrational people can already use a lot of irrational arguments. If remote operation of drones by paraplegics suddenly becomes a major part of society, so that operations like this restaurant would be a significant part of the policy debate, paraplegics would be better off and potentially not need benefits. Wouldn't that be an ideal goal?
One crucial issue is that the person who is being asked to do the work needs to feel that they can say no.
Finding ways to extract labour from people who would otherwise be a "pure burden" on society is obviously fraught with risks of exploitation.
If more than one tele-operated cafe is founded, then their employees will have exactly the same choice as most people who work in the service industry today. If only one tele-operated cafe company is ever started, then it will not be a very big social change. That's really all I'm saying.
Of course, we could imagine that one company would become gigantic and also the world's only employer of disabled people, but that concern applies equally to every commercial enterprise and people group. Any company could become a labor monopsony in the right (wrong?) environment.
What of paraplegics as restaurant managers, for instance? A related point from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy page on Affirmative Action[0]:
>Many factories and businesses prior to 1964, especially in the South, had in place overtly discriminatory policies and rules. For example, a company’s policy might have openly relegated African-Americans to the maintenance department and channeled whites into operations, sales, and management departments, where the pay and opportunities for advancement were far better. If, after passage of the Civil Rights Act, the company willingly abandoned its openly segregative policy, it could still carry forward the effects of its past segregation through other already-existing facially neutral rules. For example, a company policy that required workers to give up their seniority in one department if they transferred to another would have locked in place older African-American maintenance workers as effectively as the company’s own prior segregative rule that made them ineligible to transfer at all. Consequently, courts began striking down facially neutral rules that carried through the effects of an employer’s past discrimination, regardless of the original intent or provenance of the rules.
You're comparing a reality I am welcoming (disabled people being able to do something) with a possible future reality that I would welcome even more (the elimination of disability), along with a little bit of an even better future that might be even further away (the elimination of menial labor and the intellectual liberation of humanity). Sure, let's intellectually liberate humanity, but you aren't going to accomplish that by telling disabled people that they can't remote-operate commercial robots because you would rather them be intellectually liberated instead.
It's curious I'm being downvoted in my original comment for arguing for a more human approach to jobs and labour in society.
Past attempts to exclude political discussion from HN reflect a belief that, somehow, what Silicon Valley does can be fully understood without recourse to political thought.
The reality is that the HN community harbours readers with a wide range of political views, and those readers can downvote people with whom they disagree with total impunity. It's not good for the quality of debate, to say the least.
The same can be said about a lot of jobs. If your quit your job in a metal working shop you can't take your lathe with you, it belongs to your employer. A bus driver usually can't take the bus with him. A crane operator usually doesn't own the crane. The only thing different in this situation is that there is only one such cafe equipped with remote controled servers. But that just means we should encourage such cafes so that more spring up and workers can move to another employer with similar equipment.
> On the other hand, the idea that this could become a weapon against disabled people (why are you staying on benefits? go out and get a job for yourself, you lazy paraplegic!)
If there were enough job opportunities for disabled people, this "attack" would be entirely valid reasoning. After all they get benefits mostly because they can't participate in the job market in the same way other people can. In the reality we live in those job opportunities don't exist in sufficient quantity, so any such attacks are empty rhetoric.
>Overall, this is much more distopic than utopic
Giving disabled people a more normal life, enabling them to participate more in society, is distopic? Even ignoring any financial aspects and the interaction during the work day, just working in itself is shown to have positive effects on mental health.
Possibly you're taking it a bit far there, but at least in England I could see that being the case. The lengths they go to to stop people getting benefits are ridiculous.
For example, Scotland now has devolved powers for benefits, and are being much more generous: Having a baby? Here's £300. Is it your first? Here's another £300. Twins? Another £300. Then they make sure you can apply for all this online.
In England they tried not to have an online presence because, "we don't want to make it too easy for people to apply."
Source?
EDIT: Best Start Grant is public info though [0]
[0] https://www.gov.scot/policies/social-security/best-start-gra...
Someone may object that contracts are sacred. I don't care about contracts that are designed to conceal or perpetuate abusive behavior.
Here's some discussion from judges: https://www.buzzfeed.com/emilydugan/most-dwp-benefits-cases-...
This is what 'leaving it to the market' looks like. Now, some would say that the market should only involve decisions about where to spend your money or not, but every libertarian and market theorist I've ever talked to says that if someone is being unfairly excluded from the market they should sue for inclusion, so here we are. Now, it's true that for some businesses the costs involved in serving some customers (eg installing a ramp for wheelchairs) is likely to exceed the benefit of doing business with those customers which can hurt profitability. But given that people decided systematic exclusion was a sufficient ill to pass a law about it, either businesses make themselves reasonably accessible or a public agency does it and recoups the cost via tax.
Of course, it's often not so much the cost of the accommodation as the confrontational manner in which the issue is litigated. The culture of diametric opposition and winner-take-all outcomes that pervades our legal and political systems may be the biggest part of the problem.
Nothing scary about that, though if we get good enough at building interfaces for robots like this, the scary part could be how everyone ends up working "remotely" and we find ourselves in a WALL-E like chair all day...
If they get a contract, in most countries they'd just be remote workers with the same rights as any other worker. At many desk jobs, the employer can just lock your account and stop you from doing anything. Even a computer can do that these days. [0]
taking on the risk of owning an expensive bit of capital equipment that moves, requires maintenance and is put into use at an employer's facility doesn't sound like a fiscally sound idea for someone who has difficulties leaving their home.
As the sibling comment indicates about the UK, there's no reason why the benefits system or politics thereof has to have any connection with the reality of what disabled people can and cannot do.
The UK system has been restructured around "prove you cannot", with the interpretation of "can do occasionally with extreme effort" as "can do for a 40 hour workweek with no assistance". Many of these absurd judgements are overturned on appeal, but the goal is to discourage as many people as possible not save money or minimise bureaucracy.
On the other hand, the idea that this could become a weapon against disabled people (why are you staying on benefits? go out and get a job for yourself, you lazy paraplegic!) is... scary.
Especially given that it sounds mostly like a marketing gimmick, and that the very thing allowing them to interact with the world is not their own, but property of the store owners - i.e. they can't take the robot and move to a different caffe, they are tied to the benevolence of their boss.
Overall, this is much more distopic than utopic, and should be discouraged in this form; but the technology is interesting and could be an asset in the lives of many people.