Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen...
by neuronic on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:52AM
(#18805015)
Since when is relying on memory exclusively a good thing? It has downsides as well, particularly blind flight when using software. Sometimes a user should be required to think at least once before clicking, for example when sending money. In this case, UX should cause him to do exactly that.
Pavlovian responses to interface design play into malicious actors hands after all.
This feels like a straw man argument. Of course nicer looking design is usually worse for function. If nothing else, just sticking to ONE type of consistent design lets all users rely more on memory. They seem to assume that user interfaces are designed with the sole goal of being usable. Have they seen any modern furniture?
When they say "our results suggest that" they don't mean that the product (e.g. a web site) would be better in some sense such as making more money long term. They say it would be easier to interact with. I completely buy that. But that's the easy part of the equation to prove! The hard part is: does a site that's nicer looking according to a majority of users but 5% harder to interact with get enough extra business to offset the more difficult UX? Does the company valuation or other metrics such as ease of attracting talent improve? This is the similar to the question "would a furniture maker sell more of this chair if it was 10% more comfortable but a bit uglier?".