Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen...
by saurik on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @12:17AM
(#18804340)
> Another Responder pointed out that material design is better. ...I don't see how. ...the basic premise of 2D facsimile for real world 3D objects is still there.
Material design uses shadows to add a third dimension. The shadows cause boundaries and can help indicate parts of the interface that can move independently.
I would definitely not claim this is much better, but it is at least a little bit better.
Another Responder pointed out that material design is better. Maybe I'm ignorant but I don't see how. Perhaps icon quality/diversity is better these days but the basic premise of 2D facsimile for real world 3D objects is still there.
Personally I prefer that UI things can be easily and uniquely related to action. This can be achieved by education I. E. sliders now look like nice rounded corner progress bars of yesteryear but we have gotten used to them thru their imposition on us by G and A.
That said I have used a few very old GUI programs and their look now is jarringly uncomfortable even though the tools are great and the UI is clear.
Progress?