Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen...
by UIZealot on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @11:52PM
(#18804259)
>> Almost all of the last near-decade of work in UIs has been a mistake.
> You keep saying this, and it's just not true.
You saying it's not true doesn't make it so.
> The extreme skeuomorphism in the older iOS versions was just as maligned as flat design is today.
Citation needed. As I remember, most pundits simply had some beef with a few extreme cases of skeuomorphism in iOS 6. Nobody advocated that Apple throw the baby out with the bath water as they did in iOS 7.
> It's important to remember that the move away from pull-down menus was informed by a good deal of end-user research
Again, citation needed. Windows 95, now that's informed by a good deal of research. Everything Microsoft did starting with Windows XP? Not so much.
> You keep saying this, and it's just not true.
You saying it's not true doesn't make it so.
> The extreme skeuomorphism in the older iOS versions was just as maligned as flat design is today.
Citation needed. As I remember, most pundits simply had some beef with a few extreme cases of skeuomorphism in iOS 6. Nobody advocated that Apple throw the baby out with the bath water as they did in iOS 7.
> It's important to remember that the move away from pull-down menus was informed by a good deal of end-user research
Again, citation needed. Windows 95, now that's informed by a good deal of research. Everything Microsoft did starting with Windows XP? Not so much.