News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese Crankshafts (2012) by ajross on Monday December 31, 2018 @04:41PM (#18797211)
> I've met guys who did work for someone in the US, who then turned around and said, "You want to get paid? Sue me!" Yes, brazen as that.

I don't see how that logic is responsive. Obviously "it happens" anywhere in the world. The point was about frequency. I mean, sure, fraud like that by a machine shop probably happens in the US, but in the US it's fraud, which is a crime, and people go to jail for it. (Not to mention the fact that a machine shop that tried this would be sued for at least the liquidation value of its equipment, which is not insubstantial). So it's rare.

In China it's so common it's become a meme. It happens all the time, so much so that there's a posited "trust process" that exists to counter it. But obviously (seriously, obviously) that process doesn't work as well, because fraud is common there and rare here.

That's just silly. The Rule of Law works better than palm greasing and back watching, and to argue otherwise is just ridiculous. (And in context, holding up the PRC as an example of a libertarian wonderland is hilariously so).

(And your culture point makes the same logical mistake in reverse, assuming that since one chinese woman told a white lie and her husband was truthful that you can extrapolate honesty to a whole population. Again, frequency matters!)

Re:Chinese Crankshafts (2012) by stcredzero on Monday December 31, 2018 @08:04PM (#18798232)
Maybe I'm not reading correctly, but you keep on roaring on, as if you are saying something completely different than the comments you're replying to. Please re-read. We are actually saying the same things. No one is denying that there's more of certain kinds of fraud in China. No one is disagreeing with you that Rule of Law works a lot better in the US, nor has anyone suggested that personal relationships work better than Rule of Law. All I'm saying -- and this is something I go on about consistently -- is that cross cultural differences are commonly seen as differences in kind, when they are actually differences in degree.

I don't think you are thinking clearly and really understanding the terms you are using if you interpret a "bribery market in corruption" as some kind of "libertarian wonderland." No libertarian worth listening to would advocate for an environment without accountability and rule of law.

You've got things so near to 180 degrees turned around, it's a bit of a wonder and maybe a wee bit worrying.

(And your culture point makes the same logical mistake in reverse, assuming that since one chinese woman told a white lie and her husband was truthful that you can extrapolate honesty to a whole population. Again, frequency matters!)

No one actually says the things you're trying to put into other people's mouths. There, you're merely displaying your biases and what axes you're grinding. All I can offer is a factual account of my own anecdotal experience.

(In other words, I'm trying to have a nuanced discussion here, while you seem to be operating on the assumption that everyone's polarized at either extreme.)