[dead]
Re:How to Forget Your Mother Tongue and Remember Your Nation...
by jcranmer on Monday December 31, 2018 @03:02PM
(#18796613)
If you're going to object to the standard PIE hypothesis, you need a much, much stronger argument than "my folk etymology of one word supports my hypothesis better."
I have a decent knowledge of the history of the steppe regions, and their interactions with settled, urban populations; of the development of early civilizations within the Near East; and of the comparisons between Zoroastrianism and the Vedic pre-Hindu religion. All of that evidence very strongly supports the classic Proto-Indo-European hypothesis and very strongly counsels against Indigenous Aryan hypotheses, so you are going to need provide very compelling evidence if you want to convince anybody.
Re:How to Forget Your Mother Tongue and Remember Your Nation...
by selimthegrim on Monday December 31, 2018 @06:53PM
(#18797921)
Until running into folks like these I never understood why Ahmed Hasan Dani couldn't get a job after getting a gold medal in Sanskrit at Benares Hindu University. Now I see it wasn't just because he was the wrong kind of Kashmiri - apparently it's only worth teaching people Sanskrit if they follow the party line.
Re:How to Forget Your Mother Tongue and Remember Your Nation...
by selimthegrim on Monday December 31, 2018 @06:52PM
(#18797908)
Discover magazine had a nice article recently about the pastoralist/settled interactions at Lepenski Vir in Serbia
As conventional historians and anthropologists agree, Indo-Europeans originate as a nomadic pastoralist population from somewhere on the steppes around Ukraine and Kazakhstan. The major European branches of Celtic, Germanic, Italic, Balto-Slavic, Hellenic, and Anatolian (e.g. Hittite) spread into Europe, virtually extinguishing all the other existing languages (Basque is the only one to survive to the modern day). It's thought that this spread didn't involve any sort of violence of conquest.
The Indo-Iranian (and Indo-Aryan subbranch underneath it) is generally understood to originate from Indo-European migrations across the steppes, which would eventually come to dominate the settled regions of modern Iran through modern India as the language of the rulers and, much more slowly, eventually the language of the commoners as well. The similarities between Vedic texts and Zoroastrianism also allows us to trace the development of Zoroastrianism and Hinduism from a common set of Indo-Iranian religious beliefs.
The revisionism comes from those who do not want to believe that Hinduism arose from non-native Indian traditions. For these people, Indo-Aryans are indigenous Indian people, perhaps a continuation of the Harappan civilization. And so Indo-Aryan is Sanskrit is Vedic is Hindu is Indian, and the discovery of a culture in Syria that may have a ruling Indo-Aryan population (I should note that recent scholarship tends to believe that it did not) is therefore evidence of a commonality of culture as distant as Syria that originated in India.