Re:People not liking open source (and it's not Oracle)
by araneae on Sunday November 07, 2010 @03:14PM
(#1880208)
Exactly. In my experience, if someone wants to look at your code, they will e-mail you and ask for it. Then you e-mail it to them.
Sharing on something like sourceforge just simple isn't done. It's not because scientists are "cheating," it's because it's not part of the culture.
Re:People not liking open source (and it's not Oracle)
by possibilistic on Sunday November 07, 2010 @11:50AM
(#1879702)
I definitely agree with this. Besides, the code itself is an insignificant part of the process. Any paper will include more than enough evidence to back up its assertions and provide a path for duplicating its results.
i think the real reason for not releasing this code is time---you might be surprised at just how much effort goes into making a paper/talk/article polished. sure, you could just release the hacky code you used to do your calculations, but you'd like so much more---for it to be useful, for it to be a credit to you, for it to also do XYZ. research code is efficient in that it gets exactly what you want for the paper; it's rarely usable by anyone else. there is essentially zero payoff in academia in publishing code, and so there's no time to fulfill these desires.