> If we lived by that logic, places would steadily become worse since complaints would only be valid if you lived there before a change took place.
maybe. or maybe if this were the case it would exert a large enough downward pressure on property values that the current owner would be forced to resolve the issue before selling.
This is exactly what the current owners are trying to resolve via their complaints.. which is why their complaints are valid, even if they didn't live at the residence before the issue arose.
Edit: Hence the logic holds that if complaints are required to reduce an externality, and you simultaneously hold that complaints are only valid if they are made by residents who have lived there before said externality began, then places would only become worse.
but by "current owner" I meant the person who owned the property before the annoying circumstance began.
If we lived by that logic, places would steadily become worse since complaints would only be valid if you lived there before a change took place.
Edit: removed my analogy because that's not really the point of my comment.
Edit: would sure like to hear from others about why they disagree and why they are down-voting this.