As you point out, these standards may not be entirely realistic for a for-profit company operating in a very competitive space.
Google therefore must either take the risk that their standards will actually make them into a stronger company, or gradually compromise them for competitive advantage.
The problem with the compromise approach is that it undermines trust even more than if they'd never held themselves to such high standards in the first place, and that's where the backlash comes from.
I want Google to be the bare-knuckles, no-holds-barred, take-no-prisoners winner - for good.
In this case, it seems like they are currently doing the right thing.
Demanding reciprocity is the right thing for data portability. It's like the GPL is more restrictive license than the BSD license - and the best license for software freedom.
I doubt shareholders would really want Google to sit back and give up the game on social.