News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by earthicus on Friday December 28, 2018 @01:05AM (#18775121)
Is that really how research in CS works? Certainly we hear about grad students doing lots of the work in laboratory sciences like biology, but in more analytic subjects like mathematics or theoretical physics its not true at all. Grad students making significant contributions is extremely rare; basically all of the real research is done by tenured professors.

Can those of you who did postgrad CS tell us how much of the research is actually done by grad students vs professors?

Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by UncleMeat on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:25AM (#18777670)
CS PhD here from one of the top programs (currently in industry). Personal friends with faculty at several top schools.

Like 95% of research is done by grad students.

Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by anonymousDan on Friday December 28, 2018 @06:58AM (#18776270)
In my experience it's often (but definitely not always) the case that for new post-grad students the idea or general research direction often comes from the professor (especially if the research is funded by a grant proposal). Most of the heavy lifting is then done by the grad student with guidance and feedback from the professor. As the student matures they start to operate more independently.
Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by azhenley on Friday December 28, 2018 @09:57AM (#18777038)
In my experience (new professor), 90-95% of the work is done by grad students.

A good prof in my mind acts a mentor, providing frequent feedback on the research and contributes to writing of the paper. The feedback is often invaluable, but still just a small part in the overall amount of work compared to what the student puts in.

Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by chrisseaton on Friday December 28, 2018 @08:33AM (#18776588)
> Grad students making significant contributions is extremely rare; basically all of the real research is done by tenured professors.

...but most of these first authors (the people formally credited with doing the real work) are graduate students, so how does that fit in with your theory?

Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by earthicus on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:37PM (#18778136)
I specifically made that claim of mathematics and theoretical physics, and requested first hand accounts of how it worked in CS.
Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by chrisseaton on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:57PM (#18778275)
So how does it work in your field? Making your own significant contribution is literally the basic standard required for a PhD in most fields.
Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by earthicus on Friday December 28, 2018 @03:02PM (#18779048)
Well i think it just depends on how 'significant' you need the phd to be. As an example of what I mean, consider the first issue of this years Annals of mathematics [1] and note that there is not a single grad student on any of the papers, first author or otherwise.

[1] http://annals.math.princeton.edu/2018/188-1

Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by Ar-Curunir on Friday December 28, 2018 @06:58AM (#18776273)
While the general idea might be professor-inspired, 90% of legwork is carried out by grad students.
Re:Best Paper Awards in Computer Science since 1996 by tnecniv on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:20PM (#18778042)
Depends a bit on the professor. Young ones are more involved than older ones for a variety of reasons. In either case, the bulk of the work is done by grad students. Professors are more like managers that provide direction, feedback, etc.