Re:Powerful Photos of Life in the Old Glasgow Tenement Block...
by grey-area on Thursday December 27, 2018 @03:12PM
(#18772220)
I agree poverty is a blunt measure, but literacy, infant mortality, poverty, life expectancy are all improving globally. By almost any measure life has improved dramatically over the last hundred years. It is no longer nasty, brutish and short for the majority, and the rural life people leave for factories is not an idyll, but instead often grinding poverty and early death with no way out. That's why they leave.
Re:Powerful Photos of Life in the Old Glasgow Tenement Block...
by beat on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @10:03AM
(#18806560)
Europe went through the same things - from largely rural extreme poverty, to dirty industrial cities, to modern clean, wealthy Europe. Heck, these very photos show a step in that process, from 50 years ago, when Scotland was in the state you're so horrified about imagining China in today.
And yes, working 12 hour days in a smog-infested city is better than extreme poverty. Life isn't a socialist realist painting. Literacy is better than illiteracy. Vaccination is better than no vaccination. Water from a tap is better than water in a bucket that you have to walk to get. Etc. People don't move to the cities because country life is getting worse; they move because city life is better.
Is income a pretty measure? No. But it's a good proxy. It's more fine-grained and less messy than something like birth rate.
Re:Powerful Photos of Life in the Old Glasgow Tenement Block...
by michaelmcmillan on Thursday December 27, 2018 @03:55PM
(#18772564)
Read Enlightenment Now by Pinker!
In the end, you're judging the success of a system (capitalism) with a metric internal to that system. What does that tell you?
It's in fact so ridiculous a measure that a slave/indentured servant "earning" 5$ a day is considered a-ok in that metric.
EDIT: I'll just rememind that downvote is not a "disagree" button.