That JMAP makes it straightforward to build a rudimentary but fully functional email client gives me hope that people may experiment more than they have been. I believe that a large part of the reason that there are few email clients now is because getting a basically-functioning email client going is a surprisingly large investment of effort, and doing it well is an enormous investment.
Though that makes it sound like it would work with any email provider. It's not clear that JMAP is a protocol. "Building a JMAP email client in half an hour"?
Maybe there's not enough interest in JMAP yet, and a talk that promotes JMAP over IMAP/SMTP would be better first. Maybe the client could be prebuilt and simply presented as part of the talk as FOSS, showing the small LoC that it took and simply mentioning how little time it took. Maybe having it in multiple programming languages would help, too, to show that its simplicity is not a matter of language of choice.
Just throwing ideas out there.
The only thing I'm afraid of is the programming language, please don't pick some hipster language (e.g. invented in the past five years) or some bloated platform like Electron.
FOSDEM? Probably too late for this year, though.
I have one address hosted via outlook.com (relic from when they had a free tier for personal domains), and the bulk of email is via gmail. I have mail forwards in google domains for a few really old email addresses (just used it the other day to recover an old account). But for the most part, I would love to see some better personal mail options.
I've roughly looked at some of the mail in a box stuff, but I don't want all of DNS and the world for the domain controlled under my mail server.
Totally agree that email protocols need improvement, but there are other benefits to gmail. I'm always going to want reliable service and storage, good spam filtering (and gmail's scale allows them to do that potentially better than anybody), and the interface is pretty good. I can even use my own domain.
I don't doubt there was a time Gmail was the absolute best at spam filtering, but I would contend that time is over.
I'd hope most decent providers let you use your own domain...
It's easy to think gmail spam filtering is good if you never check the spam folder. It has filtered out some very important mails for me and others so I do my very best to disable it. Create a filter for "is:spam" and "Never send it to Spam" is the best solution I know. But despite this google might remove mails anyway.
Another big advantage is that their spam data aggregation is optional, unlike Gmail's, and solely uses the content of confirmed spam (aka, you permanently deleted it) to refine their data, so no personal data is getting hoovered up with it.
I did actually shut off offering up my spam data to the masses on FastMail, because I realized I had an edge case where the filters defining my spam as spam for everyone could be harmful.
As far as backup, I have a local Microsoft Outlook which I open every so often which pulls down all the email. I wouldn't mind a Google Takeout-esque download feature from FastMail at some point too though.
I haven't looked into backing up gmail.
With JMAP maybe we will actually see some interest in decent desktop and mobile clients for once. And also maybe we will have decent alternatives to the big players for non-techie people too.