News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Giant Step for a Chess-Playing Machine by mindgam3 on Thursday December 27, 2018 @01:22AM (#18767793)
You forgot to mention his sole grandmaster win came from a simultaneous exhibition where GM Larry Christiansen played against 35 people at once. Trust me, playing 30 boards at once is a wee bit of a handicap.

Not that I doubt his cross-disciplinary math skills or whatnot. But let's not pretend that he's anything resembling a serious chess player.

Re:One Giant Step for a Chess-Playing Machine by tashi on Thursday December 27, 2018 @03:24AM (#18768267)
I don't think I forgot to mention that, I used a hyperlink to point to it instead. As a guy who loves chess and has studied it off and on over the years, I doubt I'll ever win a game against a grandmaster under any circumstances, so it still seems impressive to me.

But even I know enough, from watching videos on YouTube that analyze some of the AlphaZero vs. Stockfish games, to appreciate that AlphaZero was playing in a style I haven't seen before. What's the threshold for someone serious enough to write a chess article?

Re:One Giant Step for a Chess-Playing Machine by mindgam3 on Thursday December 27, 2018 @02:36PM (#18771905)
Saying "Strogatz did once beat a grandmaster in chess" without specifiying that it was simultaneous exhibition is a lie by omission. I am a chess player, and I would never insult another player by claiming to have beaten him or her without specifying the format. There is a way for you to say what you want to say without exaggerating to make a point.

What's the threshold for someone serious enough to write a chess article?

There's no threshold whatsoever, as long as you communicate a respect for the game and you don't try to use chess as a metaphor to make a larger point about AI and humanity that doesn't hold up to scrutiny. If a rank amateur can appreciate that AlphaZero plays chess beautifully and wants to write about it, by all means. I happen to agree. Just please don't abuse my beloved game for marketing purposes or to win an argument.