News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by StavrosK on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:45PM (#18763792)
What did he say, exactly? This sounds like a possible use-mention distinction problem to me.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by darkpuma on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:51PM (#18763851)
Good question. I've found a transcript published by patreon: https://patreonhq.com/hate-speech-on-patreon-a9026e52c2cf?gi...

It's... pretty vitriolic. I'm not totally comfortable with even quoting the redacted version, but here goes nothing:

>“I just can’t be bothered with people who chose to treat me like this. It’s really annoying. Like, I — . You’re acting like a bunch of n_____s, just so you know. You act like white n_____s. Exactly how you describe black people acting is the impression I get dealing with the Alt Right. I’m really, I’m just not in the mood to deal with this kind of disrespect.”

>“Look, you carry on, but don’t expect me to then have a debate with one of your f__gots.…Like why would I bother?…Maybe you’re just acting like a n____r, mate? Have you considered that? Do you think white people act like this? White people are meant to be polite and respectful to one another, and you guys can’t even act like white people, it’s really amazing to me.”

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by korethr on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:33PM (#18764639)
I can't deny, that's uncomfortable to read.

Stepping back from my discomfort, and trying to understand the context in which that statement was made, the impression I get is that he's using white-supremacist stereotypes of white_people==good and black_people==bad against white supremacists. If a white supremacist holds a worldview that white people are polite and civil, and black people are the opposite, then it seems to me there is no more just and cutting insult to a white supremacist than to point out to said white supremacist that he is acting not like the paragon of white virtue he imagines himself to be, but like the black stereotypes he denigrates. The video clip linked downthread seems to support this.

IMO, this falls into the same bucket as feminists using the misogynist language of male chauvinists against them, or pointing out to a homophobe he's acting like his negative stereotype of LGBTQ people. That is, more generally, pointing out to a bigot his hypocrisy.

But if use of slurs generally associated with negative stereotypes is verboten, period, regardless of context, that worries me. There is no better way to take down bigots than to call to light the inconsistency of their ideas and hypocrisy of their behavior. And if someone who'd call out bigots can't do that safely, you've taken away a powerful tool for fighting bigotry. Worse, if you do it inconsistently, you've just handed bigots a powerful rhetorical weapon, for now they can point out your own hypocrisy to cut down your anti-bigotry position.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by makomk on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @04:12PM (#18764942)
It sounds like he's also referencing the old and tired racist tactic of arguing that they don't hate black people, just the ones who are "acting like niggers", and turning that argument back on the people who use it.

(Also, the use of slurs isn't verboten period. It's still - so far as I can tell - within the bounds of publicly-acceptable discourse for people with the correct political views to refer to black people with the wrong, conservative views as "niggers" and every other slur. Possibly even whilst threatening violence against them.)

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:53PM (#18763884)
Reading this as a straight white guy, the slurs aren't as offensive as the whole underlying philosophy and line of thinking.

Although I like that the No True Scotsman fallacy leaking through the cracks.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by leereeves on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:35PM (#18764204)
Was he espousing this philosophy or merely using the philosophy of his audience to say: "even by your own philosophy, you're wrong"?

But "white people are meant to be polite and respectful to one another" is so counterfactual it's hard to imagine anyone actually believes that.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by danso on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:02PM (#18764420)
The slurs seem more like a natural symptom of him thinking that black people act subhuman.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by EpicEng on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:13PM (#18764497)
I see him throwing the slurs people in his stream are using back at them.

>Exactly how you describe black people acting is the impression I get dealing with the Alt Right. I’m really, I’m just not in the mood to deal with this kind of disrespect.”

He's saying that these people are acting in exactly the manner they are accusing others of acting, and he's using their slurs to make the comparison.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by danso on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:21PM (#18764557)
Yeah no.

> Maybe you’re just acting like a n____r, mate? Have you considered that? Do you think white people act like this? White people are meant to be polite and respectful to one another, and you guys can’t even act like white people, it’s really amazing to me.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by microcolonel on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:36PM (#18764661)
He's speaking from their perspective, clearly.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by darkpuma on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:49PM (#18764761)
I think that's plausible but ambiguous.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by microcolonel on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @04:19PM (#18765010)
It's about as ambiguous as whether you are a secret racist. This guy is arguing directly against out-and-out unabashed racists in the conversation. How much more anti-racist does one have to be in order to make it not "ambiguous" in your eyes?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by darkpuma on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @05:39PM (#18765519)
I think that particular sentence out of context is objectively ambiguous, since that particular sentence isn't qualified with some sort of arguendo disclaimer... In context, it seems much less ambiguous.

There are a lot of people in this thread who are reading that comment as unambiguously racist. Maybe some of them are being intellectually dishonest, but I think at least some of them aren't. Generally speaking when multiple people read the same sentence and walk away with wildly different notions about what the speaker's intent was, that's an indication that ambiguous language is present.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by EpicEng on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @04:00PM (#18764840)
You're uninformed.

The commenters said that "White people are meant to be polite and respectful to one another". From what I can gather, he's not making that statement; he's throwing their own crap back at them. In other words "you people say that white people are better behaved than black people, but look at how you're acting at this very moment."

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by StavrosK on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:18PM (#18764081)
Oh, yeah, that's bad. He's not even mentioning the words, he's just using them against white people instead of black, but the way he uses them is still meant as an insult. Oops.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by asabjorn on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @07:32PM (#18766179)
Context matters. The alt-right people he targeted viewed it as an insult, so he used their own language against them and framed them as what they define as bad.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by StavrosK on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @07:36PM (#18766199)
Yes but it's an insult targeted towards black people. I'm not sure it had the impact he thought it'd have, since some white racist would just think "but I'm not black", and he just ended up kind of perpetuating the insult.

I mean, I know he didn't mean disrespect towards black people, it was just in poor taste.

[dead]
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by StavrosK on Thursday December 27, 2018 @09:04AM (#18769477)
> However, pretty weak of you to vote me down instead

Ugh, first of all, stop assuming I downvoted you, I only now saw your reply.

Second of all, it's not about actively harming people in that specific instance, it's about perpetuating the perception. Using a word as an insult implies that the target group is inferior and to be associated with it is undesirable. That's why I don't like people calling others "niggers" as I don't like people calling others "homos", or "whores" or a whole slew of other things.

If someone inside the group calls someone else a derogatory term of the group, hey, it's your own group you're harming. If it's someone outside, I try to show them that it's a shitty thing to be doing that.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by asabjorn on Thursday December 27, 2018 @10:07AM (#18769805)
Well, did you downvote me once you saw it?

With regards to your offense that is fine when it is used in this way. However, what is your evidence that anyone in that group was there as collateral damage? The target was alt-rights in a livestream with 3000 views in total, and the context of his words clearly doesn’t match your characterization.

I think no one is fooled at this point by activists working hard to find something to be offended by, so that they can use it to attack a viewpoint opponent.

Maybe Patreon will becomes the first example of a company that gets serious damage by pandering to activists.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by reitanqild on Thursday December 27, 2018 @01:19PM (#18771274)
> Well, did you downvote me once you saw it?

StavrosK couldn't possibly downvote you I think.

No account can downvote a direct reply as far as I'm aware.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by StavrosK on Thursday December 27, 2018 @10:10AM (#18769824)
> Well, did you downvote me once you saw it?

No.

> what is your evidence that anyone in that group was there as collateral damage

It doesn't matter if there was damage, it's the principle.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by asabjorn on Thursday December 27, 2018 @10:33AM (#18769993)
I agree that we should avoid any negative characterization or reduction of another individual to an unchosen group based upon immutable traits.

I know a party and an associated group in the US that need to clean up their act on this before they throw any stones in their glasshouse. Identity politics is divisive and a road to hell paved with good intentions.

If you say something to a sufficiently large group you’ll risk offending someone, so the principle you propose is too simplistic and unworkable. Who defines what is offensive and when context doesn’t matter? How many people is it ok to offend when you speak to a large group or post something online? If the audience is expanded by others, through leaks or other actions, is it still not ok?

With regards to your comments I apologize for assuming you downvoted. Somehow the downvote happens as a clockwork so there seemed to be a likely causality.

[dead]
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by StavrosK on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:08PM (#18764465)
No, it's still shitty towards blacks if a black person says it, but I'm not going to get offended on their behalf in that case.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by tomp on Thursday December 27, 2018 @03:59AM (#18768389)
But you're happy to be offended on behalf of black people when a white person says it? That makes no sense...
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by StavrosK on Thursday December 27, 2018 @09:05AM (#18769486)
If a friend of mine calls someone else a "fag" jokingly, I will tell them that's not acceptable and to cut it the fuck out, as I don't like implying that being gay is a negative. If a gay person does it, it's on them.

Insulting a group from the inside is very different from insulting it from the outside.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by danso on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:04PM (#18764437)
You believe it’s an unfair privilege that they have?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by tomp on Thursday December 27, 2018 @03:59AM (#18768390)
No, it's unprincipled.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by verall on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:07PM (#18764000)
Thank you for posting this.

Talking about Nazis or not, I don't really think this is defensible. It comes off like some kind of intra-nazi scuffle.

> "White people are meant to be respectful... you guys can't act like white people"

This is a racist statement. I dont want to call him a racist, because "racist" should be a descriptor of actions and not an identity. Instead, he sounds like someone who has little remorse for making racist statements.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by theandrewbailey on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:56PM (#18763915)
A clip was included in Sargon's first video about this incident: https://youtu.be/4ThPdCicEsg?t=238