This is sometimes awkward to discuss in public, where emotion plays better in the media, but I'm fairly certain that it's been standard government practice to do such cost benefit analysis for decades.
(If the proposal did actually exist and was rejected then it seems more likely that a politician was using the emotional argument as a convenient cover for not implementing a policy that they disagreed with for other reasons.)
See for yourself:
http://books.google.ca/books?id=8jZBksh-bUMC&lpg=PP1&...
I had cited it from memory. It wasn't paint; it was asbestos.
Nearly every government decision (e.g. where to build roads) involves calculations that put a value on human life, never mind the more obvious ones about what drugs to provide via socialized medical services.
Great, though my point still stands that scientists are often the only people who can grasp a particular issue, and should perhaps consider advocating it.
That's a good point, but on the other hand, there are many issues that are unsexy, from which activists shy away. There's a passage in Russell and Norvig's AI book that relates how the US government once asked researchers to evaluate if we should ban a toxic paint component from being used in classrooms. The researchers did a proper utility calculation; they assigned a value (say 80000$) to a child's life, then evaluated the cost vs benefit (how many children lives could be saved vs. the cost of using another paint). It turned out that banning the paint component would be beneficial. The government was outraged, "How can you assign a monetary value to a child's life???"
So they rejected the report, and didn't ban the paint.
The moral was that "Refusing to assign a value to a human life leads to its being frequently undervalued"
There's no way that any activist group will ever march to support assigning value to children's lives. Yet, it may be the right thing to do, and it could happen if we had more scientific advocacy.