Load the homepage and only allow yourself to read the most obvious 5 words on it.
What do you read? At the moment when I do that, I read: "plurty cart checkout light gloves".
Just put a nice bright tagline under plurty that says "Number 1 for rave lights" and bam!
You may want to take off the "pew pew". I am not plugged into that community. Alternate phrasing "Like Glow Sticks, Without The Suck"
Edit:
Want an intense effect for your next rave? Try a green laser -- it is magical in a dark room or at nighttime. Each laser pen is effectively a laser pointer with a detachable kaleidoscope light filter on the top. When this filter is on, the single, solid laser beam transforms into hundreds of different points of light on a surface. Too dangerous to point at a face.
edit: So that means the banner works!
I guarantee this phrase improve sales. Rave culture likes silly.
It looks like you already implemented some of the suggestions, just though I'd let you know that, as of now at least, it looks great. The path I took was reading the headline ("we sell rave gear..."), not being sure what that meant, but then seeing "Green Laser Pen". Soon as I saw that, I understood what you're about and started reading products.
So anyway, good job!
http://www.plurty.com
Previously, I had this giant "Sign up" button on the home page, but what I had forgotten was that most of the value of the site came from the ability to not have to sign up in order to buy our products. We built anonymity into it so much that you don't even have to enter your email address. This was crucial for us because nobody wants to sign up for a website that is unknown.
Also, Ilya pointed out that the most distinguishing feature of our site were the extended exposure images and that we should use it as a marketing tool. We are currently planning on replacing our text-only adwords campaign and using the images to get more clicks.
Anyway...just thought I'd add my $0.02 and thank Ilya again. It was useful advice that we really needed.