News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by bane on Sunday December 23, 2018 @11:13AM (#18746838)
It can depend on the particular U.S. State. It's sometimes useful for non-Americans to think of the U.S. like a federation of weak semi-autonomous countries. Each state more or less runs their own affairs unless there's some federal interest in which case the national interest overrides the state one. What this means for this topic is that states organize their territories in sometimes different ways that can seem sometimes bizarre to outsiders.

For example, Connecticut divides itself into eight large counties and those counties are further divided into towns. Thus the meaning of "town" in Connecticut means a geographic subdivision and may have nothing or little to do with there actually being a cluster of buildings or even any interesting population at all. In fact, in Connecticut, a city is located within a town and is subordinate to it! Towns may set their own general method of local governance but are subordinate to their counties and then to their state.

Louisiana is divided into Parishes that mapped to the Catholic Parishes present in the 19th century instead of counties and are generally run by a governmental body called a Police-Jury which is a combined legislative/executive body with enormous local powers.

Virginia is divided into counties, which may have towns and other kinds of human settlements. But cities are independent of their surrounding county and act at a parallel level to counties in terms of political power. The county seat where the county government resides may or may not be in a city, but if it is there will be a parallel and equally powerful city government in the same area. Cities in Virginia, as defined governmental territories have very controlled borders, but may have very small populations. But in other areas, the cities are so large they no longer exist within a county at all and the historic county no longer exists. This has impacts mostly for taxes, schooling and property. But practically the most you would notice is that you could eat at a restaurant on one side of a street and cross to the other to get some coffee and pay a different sales tax on either side.

It goes on from there. From a practical standpoint, it almost entirely affects the locals and can be a deciding factor with where people choose to live. For outsiders, it doesn't matter much except that your sales tax might be highly variable as you transit through local governing zones.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by joe_the_user on Sunday December 23, 2018 @09:48PM (#18749935)
I would note that when you say "locals", you don't just mean the residents of whatever county, town, perish or whatch-doogle. You mean people who've had some incentive to research the mess. Because a lot of average residents of these areas either don't know their crazy ins-and-outs or don't know these by-laws are unique to their area.

I mean, from the air, from a car passing through, etc, the US appears very uniform, more uniform than most of Europe or other parts of the world and a lot of people here take that uniformity as a uniform administration. Moreover, there is a bit more uniformity than the ridiculous administrative rules indicates - zones, policing, codes and so-forth are unified by private entities and generally enacted to achieve the appearance of a uniform country.

Note: Also, the multitude of administrative apparatuses here aren't equivalent of, say, two or twenty fused nations threatening to break apart. The US unified this way and the over mess is much of a way for local to hoard their power, rip-off outsiders, etc.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by larrik on Sunday December 23, 2018 @06:49PM (#18749230)
> In fact, in Connecticut, a city is located within a town and is subordinate to it! Towns may set their own general method of local governance but are subordinate to their counties and then to their state.

Connecticut doesn't actually have county government. Counties are just a way of roughly collecting towns together.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by tboyd47 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @12:54PM (#18747339)
> It's sometimes useful for non-Americans to think of the U.S. like a federation of weak semi-autonomous countries.

That may have been true in the 18th and 19th century, but since the early 1900s, I don't think it's accurate to say that anymore. Nearly every state power has been checked by the federal court system at some point during the 20th century [0].

I didn't know about the Police-Jury system, but it's surely the exception. Wouldn't you agree that state and local governments mostly act within the bounds defined by the federal government?

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_R...

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by bane on Sunday December 23, 2018 @01:08PM (#18747410)
> Wouldn't you agree that state and local governments mostly act within the bounds defined by the federal government?

I agree that the Federal government trumps the State government, but I'm not sure that I envision it as "bounds defined by" and more as whenever the random walk of the Federal government intersects with a more local one, the Fed wins. There are plenty of areas that the Federal government can't be bothered to get involved and the more local governments fill in those niches. For example, the Federal government really doesn't care much about local zoning laws or building offsets from city streets and such.

But I can also definitely see how it could be viewed as you describe in many cases as well.

One thing that I do think is interesting is how poorly EU citizens understand the history (and mistakes!) made in systems like the U.S. to learn and model the future of the EU from.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by quanticle on Sunday December 23, 2018 @03:34PM (#18748157)
I agree that the Federal government trumps the State government, but I'm not sure that I envision it as "bounds defined by" and more as whenever the random walk of the Federal government intersects with a more local one, the Fed wins.

Even that isn't always true. In many notable cases (marijuana, gay marriage, segregation) states openly defied the federal government and the federal government let things stand because it would cost too much to intervene to get the states to obey the federal government.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by SllX on Sunday December 23, 2018 @08:51PM (#18749727)
Depends on what you mean by defy.

What often gets lost in political debate is that there is Federal law enforcement and then there is State law enforcement. For the purposes of the US Constitution, local law enforcement is State law enforcement, even if a given State might draw a distinction themselves. It is helpful to remember that the US Constitution is architected to recognize three types of entities: US Government, States, and foreign governments. Off the top of my head I couldn’t tell you if it groups tribal governments into foreign governments or distinguishes them from those categories, but for the purposes of this conversation they’re closer to States than to foreign governments.

So whether you have counties, boroughs, townships, incorporated cities, school districts, water boards, parishes, independent cities, consolidated cities and counties, villages, capital territories or completely unorganized territory; none of this matters looking from the top down because those are all part of the “States”, and Federal law doesn’t really have to care about those details. As long as there is some kind of work organization there, the Feds can work with them, make agreements and negotiate with whoever has jurisdiction over whatever in whichever State.

What this also means is that States and/or their (for the purposes Federal convenience) subordinate entities can make laws and enforce them according to their own constitutions, laws and general policies, and the Federal government has its own parallel set of laws, courts, law enforcement officers, prisons and policies. Parallel, not higher. Your local police department is paid out of your local government’s budget, not out of the Federal budget.

So let’s take one of your example’s up there: marijuana. As far as the State of California or Washington is concerned, weed is fine. They aren’t going to spend money raiding pot farms, they’re going to tax them. According to their laws, it is generally legal for medicinal and recreational use, so you will not be arrested by a State law enforcement officer, dragged off to a State court and stuffed into a State prison for possession, use, sale or purchase provided proper procedures are observed.

The Feds though? They might still do all of that in this completely parallel legal system over here though. They can’t change* California or Washington law, but residents in these States are still subject to Federal law.

Well what about marriage? Well while Congress has the power to regulate substances offered for sale in this country, commerce clause and all that, the Constitution doesn’t say anything about giving Congress or the President license to determine what is and isn’t a lawful marriage in any of the States. According to the 10th amendment, this is clearly reserved for the States since it is a civil issue not specifically reserved for Congress. So unless you can twist the commerce clause to somehow cover marriage, then Congress doesn’t really have a say. No, this didn’t stop all 535 of them from sharing their opinions the very second Gavin Newsom issued that first same-sex marriage certificate, but that was about the extent of what they could do. All of the real debate was largely contained to internal State politics and about the most a Congressional candidate could give was their opinion.

What about the Defense of Marriage Act? Here’s where it got only slightly tricky, at least until it was determined to be unconstitutional anyway. Actually that’s pretty much the end of it: it was determined to be unconstitutional. While the States determine who can be married, Congress has given the Federal government the power to offer certain benefits including tax benefits to married couples, which is fine, and DOMA essentially barred same-sex married couples from receiving these benefits, and granted States license to ignore same-sex marriage certificates issued by other States which they would otherwise be obliged to recognize under some other clause of the Constitution.

Then SCOTUS struck down Section 3, later Section 5 and rendered Section 2 a casualty in the process. Basically the system worked as designed, even though it was law for close to twenty years.

It is fair to say, that when Federal law and State law are in conflict, Federal law does trump State law in most cases. What gets missed is that the Federal government must enforce Federal law. It can get States to help, by coercion or agreement, but sometimes that doesn’t work. That’s why Sanctuary City/State laws can also exist: the States are charged with enforcing their own laws without any expectation of assistance from the FBI or ICE, and it goes both ways: FBI and ICE have to be able to enforce immigration and other Federal laws, with or without assistance from any State they are operating within because something like immigration is explicitly under the jurisdiction of the Congress and Federal government. Sometimes there is a societal conflict, or values conflict, but unless there is a legal conflict, none of that actually matters to the Constitution and by extension, SCOTUS.

tl;dr: States/local govs employ their own law enforcement and enforce State/local laws. The Feds employ their own Federal law enforcement to employ Federal law. Neither actually works for the other, but rather in parallel and it is largely up to their discretion when and if to cooperate.

* The Feds sometimes make grants for very specific agreements, generally if they want a special kind if cooperation they have to pay for it, but otherwise your police compensation packages come out of your local budget.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by quanticle on Monday December 24, 2018 @03:27AM (#18751117)
The enforcement part is what I was getting at. It's all well and good for the federal government to make a law that says that marijuana is illegal, or that whites and African Americans must go to the same schools. But nothing about those laws alters facts on the ground without resources and manpower devoted to enforcement. The allocation of those resources and manpower requires political will, and when that political will is lacking, laws can be passed, court decisions can be made, and no facts on the ground will change.

Like you pointed out, what enables the "defiance" of state governments in the face of the federal government is the fact that, in some cases, the federal government has decided that it's not worth causing further political unrest to quash this defiance. This is why we don't see raids on marijuana retailers in Washington and Colorado. In other cases, that political will does exist, as we saw when Lyndon Johnson called out the National Guard to force the integration of schools in the Jim Crow South.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by pm90 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @03:37PM (#18748164)
They're not the same though. Even though Americans consider their state identities to be strong and unique, if you look at how states are generally organized in the old world, its generally by ethnicity, language or some other very strong form of strong shared identity. So while a person from California and Texas might be very different, the difference is likely much smaller than b/w a French person and a German person (although of course this varies).

There is also the very strong belief in, and the common acceptance of, American identity as being the more defining identity, whereas not so much in the EU.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by lsc on Sunday December 23, 2018 @07:39PM (#18749445)
>if you look at how states are generally organized in the old world, its generally by ethnicity, language or some other very strong form of strong shared identity.

While true, it is important to remember that this is a 19th/20th century type thing. Germany became unified around cultural/ethnic lines in 1871 (in France! so much of world war one was about the fallout from the wars of german unification, just like so much of the wars of german unification were fallout from the Napoleonic wars.) Italy became unified around cultural/ethnic lines in like 1860.

Before this, the individual "german" states were not politically unified in any sort of way; they all belonged to whatever multi-ethnic empire invaded them last, and they were more likely to war with oneanother than, say, with France.

My point here is that ethnic nationalism looks like the old-world default today, but this is a fairly recent thing.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by quanticle on Monday December 24, 2018 @03:30AM (#18751125)
I would also point out that, in the US, the idea that American identity trumps state identity is something that really only came into its own after the Civil War. When the Civil War broke out, a large number of the United States' senior officers chose to put state identity ahead of national identity and fight with the Confederate States of America, knowing full well that doing so would cause them to break their vow to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States of America.
Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by huehehue on Sunday December 23, 2018 @02:53PM (#18747956)
Within the bounds of federal law but still quite different. Guns, marijuana, open containers (alcohol), driving (80mph is reckless driving in VA, but totally legal elsewhere), abortion, and more all vary by state.

I've even heard of state border checks in the southwest (mostly "papers please" immigrant checks...). Still not nearly as tight-knit as one would think.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by AdrianB1 on Sunday December 23, 2018 @07:45PM (#18749470)
"It's sometimes useful for non-Americans to think of the U.S. like a federation of weak semi-autonomous countries." That would be helpful if it would be true. In old' Europe a the equivalent of a county or city does not have any power to enact and enforce legislation, all the laws are country-wide and enforced by the national police; the only local law enforcement is for parking and minor (no criminal record) misdemeanors. From what I know many counties in US have the power to regulate areas that can be felonies if disobeyed (like gun regulations), something like that is unbelievable around here.
Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by jganetsk on Sunday December 23, 2018 @08:43PM (#18749702)
I think the post was referring to states, not counties, when referring to "countries".
Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by AdrianB1 on Monday December 24, 2018 @05:26AM (#18751453)
Yes, it was about states, but these states are not equivalent to European states, but with counties because in Europe the lowest level to adopt a law is the state, in US is the county.
Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by pard68 on Monday December 24, 2018 @10:01AM (#18752402)
Even this rule isn't always true. In Virginia a city can be independent, which means the city and county are the same government.

It New England, where counties don't really have much power and the towns have the power that counties generally have in other States.

Or Connecticut, where counties only exist because there are federal forms you cannot complete without listing a county.

I am sure there are other exceptions too, but these are the places I have lived, and thus know.

Re:Why American cities are weirdly shaped by kiriakasis on Thursday December 27, 2018 @04:20PM (#18772744)
> Europe the lowest level to adopt a law is the state

This does not really makes any sense. Scotland has a parliament, in Italy some regions have special local powers, and I believe many other countries have various kinds of exceptions.