News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by jbail on Friday November 05, 2010 @03:16PM (#1874460)
I have some trouble understanding this statement: "...willfully infringing on the copyrights of 24 songs by making them available for sharing."

How do you infringe a copyright by sharing something? Is sharing tantamount to distributing?

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by soiz on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:57PM (#1875430)
> "making them available for sharing."

It's a really big slippery slope:

The jury was instructed that merely "making available" sufficed to constitute an infringement of the plaintiffs' distribution right, even without proof of any actual distribution.[1][11][12] The issue of whether copyright infringement required actual distribution was raised by the defense during examination of Sony BMG's head of litigation on the first day of trial, but the court sustained the plaintiffs' objection and did not permit the topic to be revisited until jury instructions were prepared just before the end of the trial.[12] Despite disagreement from the defense, the court proceeded to interpret making available as distribution for purposes of instructing the jury.[12]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_v._Thomas

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by sp332 on Friday November 05, 2010 @03:35PM (#1874535)
Yeah, but I think the prosecution was trying to make the case that it's an even BIGGER deal than distributing for profit. If I pay money for a bootleg disc, I won't just give it away when I'm done, because it represents some money to me. But if I get a song for free, then I'm more likely to redistribute further. So the really twisted argument is that non-commercial sharing is even more damaging to the music industry than for-profit sharing, and therefore she should be penalized more than commercial pirates.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by nkassis on Friday November 05, 2010 @03:49PM (#1874603)
forget the sharing part. the available is the big issue. Making them available isn't the same as distributing.