One interesting difference between the US system and the parliamentary system is how coalitions work. In one sense, US parties are themselves coalitions already. Democrats are a coalition between labor, feminists, environmentalists, minorities, leftists, civil libertarians, and various single-issue voters; Republicans are a coalition between militarists, free-marketers, right-wing Christians of all denominations, and various single-issue voters. If you're a gun-owning trade unionist, who are you going to vote for? In practice, places with a lot of gun owning trade unionists end up with pro-gun Democrats and pro-union Republicans, and then they have to dynamically form coalitions just like a parliamentary system. Likewise, you don't get huge factions of the Labour party voting against a Labour PM in Parliament unless they want to start something; whereas you do get that in the US system. There are even bipartisan coalitions, between conservative Democrats and Republicans during the Reagan years, or even single-issue coalitions across both parties (though these are diminishing--"pro-life" Democrats and "pro-choice" Republicans have become increasingly ostracized and purged from their respective parties, for instance). So in effect, the US system allows dynamic coalitions to form between individual members of Congress, while a PR-based parliamentary system (theoretically) allows dynamic coalitions to form between multitudes of small parties. (In practice, there are still pretty tight upper bounds on how many different parties you can have, for reasons best described as "brand recognition".) What's the effect? In a parliament, it's harder to form a coalition, but once formed the coalition effectively runs the table until someone decides to start over again. In the US system, every individual piece of legislation can pass or fail, and it's an errand to shove it though.
Gridlock happens for two reasons: one, the US system is designed to gridlock, two, because opposing sides are learning to fully utilize this design rather than cooperate against it. The US system is designed to gridlock by having a bicameral legislature (most parliaments are effectively unicameral) with an independent executive and veto. The rules of each house require bills to pass through committees (and, in some cases, cloture) before coming up for a vote. Then you need an executive signature, or else you have to go through the legislative system again with higher thresholds for passing. Additionally, each house, as well as the executive, is elected separately. Unless each house is controlled by the same party as the President, you have to compromise to get anything done (or, alternately, one side can choose to completely obstruct the other). Even if each house is controlled by the same party as the President, you have to get everyone within the party to cooperate.
"With no political parties, every single vote would be about political dealmaking and organizing politicians. We would never get anything done."? Every single vote is already about political dealmaking and organizing politicians. That's how the US system works.
There was never any individual who had a 3/5 vote; this is a misconception. Slaves were not allowed to vote at all. Instead, they were counted as 3/5 of a person on the census, which was used to distribute seats in the House and electoral votes.
Slave owners wanted slaves to be counted as full people, which would have increased the south's political power. Those opposed to slavery wanted slaves to not be counted, thereby decreasing the south's political power.
Those who complain that slaves were "only" counted as 3/5 of a person are (accidentally) making a statement in favor of increasing the power of slave owners.
> "the two party system is meant to make government more agile and less risk averse."
Far from it. The system with two chambers of Congress plus an executive is meant to create gridlock. It's meant to prevent a small majority from being able to ram through an agenda.
As a result of the 3/5 compromise, the South usually had an edge in the House of Representatives and in electing the President, but the North had an edge in the Senate, and therefore neither side could pass slavery-related legislation. This was intentional. The US legislative system is designed to make it difficult to pass laws without extremely broad support, because the founding fathers (despite all their flaws) recognized how dangerous it would be if a narrow edge in population could be transformed into a huge edge in legislative power.
The rough draft of the Declaration of Independence is interesting: http://www.princeton.edu/~tjpapers/declaration/declaration.h...
"he has waged cruel war against human nature itself, violating it’s most sacred rights of life & liberty in the persons of a distant people who never offended him, captivating & carrying them into slavery in another hemisphere, or to incur miserable death in their transportation thither. this piratical warfare, the opprobrium of infidel powers, is the warfare of the CHRISTIAN king of Great Britain. determined to keep open a market where MEN should be bought & sold, he has prostituted his negative for suppressing every legislative attempt to prohibit or to restrain this execrable commerce:[11] and that this assemblage of horrors might want no fact of distinguished die, he is now exciting those very people to rise in arms among us, and to purchase that liberty of which he has deprived them, by murdering the people upon whom he also obtruded them; thus paying off former crimes committed against the liberties of one people, with crimes which he urges them to commit against the lives of another."
I actually think you couldn't get away with some of that stuff today.
Theoretically, the two party system is meant to make government more agile and less risk averse. It is supposed to ensure a party is, temporarily, in charge and able to accomplish its political agenda. In multiparty systems, there is frequent political deadlock as parties must negotiate to literally "form a government", or get enough of an alliance between people to mobilize 51% of the voting power. If you read international press, you often hear about the "dissolution of the government" in various civilized countries. This means they've failed in maintaining or forming a coalition, and must go back to political dealings in order to (in most cases) elect a prime minister and get behind a political agenda. These multiparty systems are therefore risk averse, and theoretically worse at achieving widespread governmental action.
I keep using the word "theoretical" because of our obvious governmental gridlock in the United States. But to look at things like the stimulus package and the health care bill, and it's not so clear that we're unable to pass large pieces of legislation.
With no political parties, every single vote would be about political dealmaking and organizing politicians. We would never get anything done. I'm not necessarily saying we have the right system, or even a great system, just that it isn't quite so easy to say "get rid of parties".
Now, to the second point. Jefferson? Puh-lease! I can't stand the frequent popular allusions to Jefferson the saint. This man was a great part of our country and one of the most important thinkers of his time. But he also wrote anti-government propaganda from the office of the vice presidency and had a near-blood fued with George Washington, John Adams, and Alexander Hamilton.
Jefferson wouldn't roll over in his grave at this political language; he would be saying things far worse. If he sprang back to life today, he would suggest dissolving the federal government, abolishing any standing military, closing down capital institutions to promote an agrarian lifestyle, and letting Virginia negotiate a peace treaty with France. Let's not even talk about just what part of our society would have a real vote and which part would have 3/5 of one. I mean, can we be a little more reasonable with this founding father stuff?