However, none of the Little ___er books are, of themselves, good ways to learn to use the language they are in; they're more like finger exercises when learning piano -- they reinforce your mental muscles to make thinking in the right way for those languages feel more natural.
However, where "The Little _____er" books excel and overcome all other teaching formats I've seen is in introducing complex paradigm-shifting concepts in a way that is digestable in tiny chunks.
Concepts such as monads, zippers and list comprehension are exactly the the type of concepts that are very difficult to teach/explain using common teaching approaches that "tell, but do not show"
The socratic method used in "The Little Schemer" makes sure to dismantle these extremely abstract concepts into atoms '(pun intended). You really need to understand each atomic piece before you move on.
In most explanations of monads the teacher rattles off a long run-on sentence that touches on several facets of a concept such as monads, making it all that much harder to digest. In fact, most sentences/paragraphs attempting to explaining monads just cause the learner to choke on the terseness and density of information being communicated in one utterance.
The way I see it, both types of books are very valuable. The Little Schemer teaches recursion as a concept better than any other text I've seen. I've never seen anything else that come close. In fact, most texts that touch on recursion quickly move into comparing it to iteration both in form and performance. SICP is an example of a teaching resource that does this. If I remember correctly, the first time you really see recursion in SICP is when the book discusses Ackermann's function and the pros and cons of recursion versus iteration.
I'd like to see the little Erlanger too actually.
http://prof.beuth-hochschule.de/fileadmin/user/scheffler/Leh...
Learn Haskell the Hard Way
Learn Erlang the Hard Way
Learn Common Lisp the Hard Way
Learn R the Hard Way
Besides a "Learn X the Hard Way", I would actually like to see more people try to recreate the style of "The Little Scheme", which uses the socratic method to teach the learner. I think the socratic method requires the user to rack their brain a bit more, but results in much greater enjoyment and retention.
I would much prefer to see these two:
"The Little Haskeller"
"The Little Erlanger"
For example, it would be brilliant if someone can explain monads and list comprehension with the same eloquence as The Little Schemer explains currying and YCombinator.