1. Having candidates review each other seems like a good way to have the worst candidates float to the top. If you're in a contest with your competitors, given the option to knock the best options out of the race, wouldn't you do so? It seems like you're taking an overly optimistic view of human nature.
2. Having a large portion of the election based on randomness seems like it would diminish voter turnout even further. I understand its an attempt to reduce the noise created by the surrounded hype of a candidate, and that it would cause people to research these people on their own, but I dont think that would happen. I think people would see 2 random people, have no interest in either of them at a surface value, and then not vote as a result.
3. I dislike your criteria for selecting candidates, particularly for financial value. I don't think that a wealthy person is necessarily any more qualified than a poor man. I like the idea that the common man is able to obtain a position of power, regardless of background, but maybe I've watched Mr Smith Goes to Washington too many times.
I do agree that there's an issue with polarization, but I think that at the end of the day, you'll still have two candidates, and that you'll end up with polarization anyways. At the same time, I think there are problems with having too many candidate options, as I mentioned in my other post in this thread. Maybe 2 is too few, and 10 is too many, and theres a happy medium in the middle somewhere.
In the later rounds, though, it might be a problem. One idea I thought of is that "honey pot" applications of known awful candidates get planted in the mix, and if you give a top grade to one of these awful applicants, you're vote is disqualified.
But overall you may be right - the variation in which people outside the election are allowed to vote would probably be better.
2) Here's a fundamental question - should voting and elections be viewed as a means to an end? Or an end in itself? If you view voting as an end in itself, that's essentially a religious claim, and there's no grounds for debate. But if you view voting as a means to an end, I have no problem excluding people who aren't willing to put in the time to learn about the candidates. I would much rather have people not vote at all then vote based on slogans and sound bites.
3) The financial requirement ( the median income or about $40k in net worth) is not very steep. By definition, an average person who saves 10% of their income a year will be able to meet the requirement within ten years. I want my Representatives to be competent, experienced, wise, long-term-thinking individuals. If a person cannot meet that requirement, it means that they are either a) young b) incapable or unwilling of holding down an average job c) a live-for-the-moment spender. I have no problem excluding such people from office.
Polarization happens not because of the two candidates, but because of party spirit. Party spirit is something that happens over time, its the result of agitators who cultivate a voting block by spreading and ideology, convincing people to pledge themselves in solidarity, etc.
You can have just as many problems with multiple parties. For instance, the Weimar Republic had six major parties, yet it is among the worst examples of the dangers of party politics in history. The problem with our two party system is not bi-polarization, or a lack of choice. The problem is as Noah Webster said - its party spirit. And the problem of party spirit will be bad with two, three or six parties.
A zero-information voter picking between two candidates is 50% likely to choose the better candidate. Slogans & sound-bites are designed to efficiently (i.e. at low cognitive cost) deliver a message which will inform a voter. If a slogan is totally useless, it leaves me where I was before, at 50%. If some are slightly helpful, I become a slightly better voter, e.g. 50.0001% likely to choose the better candidate.
Now let's start with a group of high-information, analytical voters who spent costly time and energy making a decision -- these people should definitely vote, as they're (say) 60% likely to choose the right person. Now, adding any number of additional 50.0001% voters only makes the better outcome more likely. So we should try to include as many low-information voters as possible.
There are some ways in which slogans could still be bad. For example, let's say that slogans are in general more easily constructed by "bad" candidates, people who are unqualified for governance (not that slogans have zero correlation with quality, they're negatively correlated). This seems very unlikely and probably requires a radical theory for the function of language. Another example, somewhat narrower: let's say sloganeering is consistently better at selling certain ideas (e.g. low taxes, xenophobia) over others that inherently require more cognitive energy. This seems plausible, but it also seems to me that both "good" and "bad" slogans can have inordinate power given certain conditions in education and culture, so flaws are likely temporary and can be remediated by work in those areas.
Have you ever been in the back office of a typical political campaign? All slogans and ads are designed foremost to elect the candidate, not to inform the voter. An ad will be as deceptive as possible without overstepping the bounds into an outright factual lie (simply because factual lies are easy to double check). This is politics 101, I'm shocked that anyone could believe that slogans and sound bites are information devices.
Since the purpose of a slogan is to deceive, the more susceptible voting is to slogans, the worse the outcomes will be. Also, the feedback loop is such that overtime the candidates out compete each other with the base, negative, demagoguing slogans.
The all time worst case of this Germany. Under the non-democratic, absolute monarchy of Frederick II the government invited the Jews into the country to start businesses and grow the economy. But over the course of the 1800's Germany got an elected parliament, and then a universal suffrage. Over time politicians out competed each other in blaming problems on the "other" (the Jews). The first anti-semite politicians in the late 1800's were fairly mild, but the feedback loop made things worse, culminating in Hitler. Only after World War II the did the U.S. written constitution ban jingoistic and racist speech, and restore some sanity to politics.
In general, there are far more ways to be wrong than to be right. Any selection factor which does not select for truth, will select for falsehood. Since the selection process for sloganeering does not reward truth, we can expect it to reward falsehood.
Education is a partial-remedy, but there are limits to how well you can educate anyone. Plus, it raises the new question - who chooses the educators? What if say, one political party captures the education system (which is what has happened in the U.S.)? Essentially what you end up with a hybrid between theocracy (government by the ideological/information authorities) and democracy. Since theocracy is also quite a lousy form of government, if I wanted to improve democracy by splicing in a hybrid gene, I would choose one other than theocracy.
Yes. I've had many roles including leadership positions in political campaigns, and including positions where I crafted official campaign language. I have many friends who have held state directorships or higher roles in winning presidential (and other) campaigns. However, politics has not been my main livelihood, so I think I'm informed while also avoiding extremes of idealism (and cynicism) on this front.
Slogans are certainly short-cuts (reductive), tendentious and often misleading. They are totally partisan, but they are also informative. It's certainly upset me when one candidate can spend a lot to get their misleading slogan out and we don't have the money to get our counter-slogan out. I regret the crucial role of money generally in U.S. democracy. However, "slogans" are not "money", and I do think sloganeering/ads are positive, not negative (and also not optimal). Also "slogans" are not "factionalism" -- another problem that I think you are right to be interested in and concerned with (but one that is very difficult to analyze). Also "slogans" are not negativism or necessarily fear-based even if it maybe seems like that right now; in '08, both U.S. pres. candidates emphasized mostly positive/uplifting (typically low-info) slogans.
Since the purpose of a slogan is to deceive, the more susceptible voting is to slogans, the worse the outcomes will be.
This is not right, for several reasons.
First, in practical terms: since outright lies (often) get caught, provocative statements that have some grain of truth are the ones that get picked up. These competing slogans are often stupid (very low signal-to-noise ratio), but the noise -- on average -- cancels out, resulting in people on average getting slightly better chances to make the right decision. E.g.: CA doesn't get every proposition right, but through the haze of slogans back and forth on -- say, prop 23 -- people make the right choice far more often than can be attributed to chance. Yet, all but the very, very few most informed voters seem to be voting based on the slogan/ad/heuristic that mysteriously resonated with them the most.
Second, from a logical perspective: in a 2-person election we start from a fair coin-flip. How do slogans make things worse? Do they "crowd out" intelligent analysis, so that what could have been 55% chance to get the right person becomes a 50% chance? Crowding-out presumes fixed amount of communication bandwidth, which seems for all practical purposes false. Or do you imagine that somehow slogans make the election worse than a coin-flip, taking a 50% chance of success down to only a 40% chance? I can't see how you'd reach that conclusion without a very elaborate and speculative theory.
I differ on Germany; that historical pathology developed through the action of intellectuals, artists, economists, and philosophers, as well as through the compliance of apathetic and ignorant people. Slogans played a role along with every other form of communication, but we can't single out that form of communication -- even though some people may know them better than they know Baeumler or Riefenstahl. Additionally, I don't think post-WWII limitations on German political speech were eliminations of jingoes or slogans: what's criminalized is all endorsements, both sloganeering and seriously intellectual, of certain ideas.
Agree with your concern about partisan capture of education; perhaps isolating curriculum development from elected officials mitigates. Culture somewhat helps, though there are few countries with strong, practical free-speech protections.
1) I think that the problem is that you've created a competition, and that as a result, people would vote against each other. You're probably correct that people do typically vote for candidates without self interest, but I think that the problem is you've pitted people against each other. If I've entered a race, I already think that I am the best option, and will take action to help my success. This is almost like the prisoners dilemna, in that voters almost assume that others will act in self interest, and as a result do the same. I think maybe you just have a more optimistic view of how people will act in this case than I do.
2) I don't think we should dismiss people from voting for any reason, or say that a lower voter turnout would be a good thing because it's focusing on the people who actually "care". I think that in some ways giving people party lines is a good thing in some ways because it allows them to vote without necessarily needing to do research into a candidate. If I personally identify myself as a liberal, I don't have to do much research before voting democrat, and in fact, researching candidates is probably only going to strengthen my opinion of them both. I'm by no means saying this is an ideal situation, and it is certainly one of the main problems with a partied system. But I think if you make voting something thats only available to those with enough time to research it then I think you run the risk of misrepresenting an extremely large portion of the country, ending up with something chosen by an "elite" and I almost feel that this is a worse option than having people vote from their gut.
3) I think this is way off base. I can think of some pretty outstanding members of our society who choose a path for ethical and moral reasons outside of financial gain. Teachers are a great example. They are educated citizens working for the benefit of society, but some of them sure as hell don't make 40k. Should we exclude people like this because they chose a path that didn't give them the most money? Having a high paying job doesn't necessarily mean that you're educated, or a frugal person for that matter.
As I hinted at above, I guess I don't mind the party line voting. I don't mind the labeling it provides because, as I said, I think it encourages voter turnout. If you're given two candidates, and you have to choose between them, without labeling them as liberal or democrat, is a person significantly more likely to choose a different candidate than they would have with the label? If hypothetically Sarah Palin ran against Obama, and we didn't label them as democrat and republican, would voters choose a different candidate than if we had?
Again, I really do appreciate your response, and I'm sorry if I seem combative, I just like the debate.
For 2) - To summarize, your objection is that only the elites would only care vote, thus the elites would oppress the masses? But if the masses noticed they were getting oppressed, wouldn't they take the time to vote? The case in which they don't care to vote is when the government is being well run, which by definition, is a good outcome. The failure case is actually that the people who have the most time to vote would end up being the lazy/idle who aren't busy working or raising a family.
For 3) filtering based on net wealth is a crude measure for sure, but the goal is results in the aggregate. In general, people with a net worth above the median income are more capable, responsible, experienced and longer term thinking. Yet the wealth requirement is not so high you're filtering out all but the wealthy. The bulk of the voters will be the responsible middle class. Will it filter out some responsible people and allow in some irresponsible people? Sure - but its only a first pass filter. As for teachers, I actually wouldn't allow any government employee to vote. Its a complete conflict of interest. But if teachers were allowed to vote, they wouldn't be prevented by income alone. Sure starting teachers often make about 75% of median income. But they do move up in pay in a few years, plus they have income during the summer. A teacher who saved 10-15% a year (which is low when you include paying down a mortgage as saving) would be able to hold office when they are around 35, which is fine with me. (I also disagree that teachers are working for the betterment of society more so than anyone else. A teacher chooses the job because it provides a secure, ample paycheck and because they enjoy the pleasure of influencing other people (or to put it more crassly, the pleasures of power))
"The old Italian toxicologists are said to have always arranged their discoveries in a series of three terms—first the poison, next the antidote, thirdly the drug which neutralised the antidote. The antidote to the fundamental infirmities of democracy was Representation, but the drug that now defeats it is the Caucus [political party]" http://books.google.com/books?id=42YpAAAAYAAJ&dq=Popular...
And Noah Webster eloquently states the fundamental problem with party politics:
<blockquote>
"...nothing is more dangerous to the cause of truth and liberty than a party spirit. When men are once united, in whatever form, or upon whatever occasion, the union creates a partiality or friendship for each member of the party or society. A coalition for any purpose creates an attachment, and inspires a confidence in the individuals of the party, which does not die with the cause which united them; but continues, and extends to every other object of social intercourse."
"Thus we see men first united in some system of religious faith, generally agree in their political opinions. Natives of the same country, even in a foreign country, unite and form a separate private society. The Masons feel attached to each other, though in distant parts of the world."
"The same may be said of Episcopalians, Quakers, Presbyterians, Roman Catholics, Federalists, and Antifederalists, mechanic societies, chambers of commerce, Jacobin and Democratic societies. It is altogether immaterial what circumstance first unites a number of men into a society; whether they first rally round the church, a square and compass, a cross, or a cap; the general effect is always the same; while the union continues, the members of the association feel a particular confidence in each other, which leads them to believe each other's opinions, to catch each other's passions, and to act in concert on every question in which they are interested."
"Hence arises what is called bigotry or illiberality. Persons who are united on any occasion, are more apt to believe the prevailing opinions of their society, than the prevailing opinions of another society. They examine their own creeds more fully, (and perhaps with a mind predisposed to believe them), than they do the creeds of other societies. Hence the full persuasion in every society that theirs is right; and if I am right, others of course are wrong." http://books.google.com/books?id=89QDAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA1&...
</blockquote>
I agree with Webster, and disagree with Scott Adams on the reason why parties are bad. The problem with parties is not the money they raise. The problem is the polarization they create, and how each party's interpretation of events becomes warped in a way that makes their own side always right, and the other side always wrong. Overtime it means that both sides end up being half-brained - and no one has the ability to really solve problems.
That said, banning parties is a non-trivial problem. If you just ban the nominal form, they will take some other form under a slightly different name. I think you would have to go all the way and perhaps create a complete ban on campaigning and campaign promises. Rather than having debates and speeches, candidates would participate in nationally televised job interviews that would talk about the candidates background and problem solving abilities.
It may also be that integrating lotteries and randomness into the election would help with the public choice problem. I have thoughts on a better election design here: http://intellectual-detox.com/the-lottery-election-a-better-...