Re:The Last Secrets of Skull and Bones (1977)
by wl on Friday December 21, 2018 @10:55AM
(#18734061)
These kinds of organizations generally don't exist to have a public impact. They exist to transform individuals.
> Is it a private matter if someone held on trial is the judge's boss in a secret organization they both belong to?
A judge has an obligation to recuse where there's a conflict of interest, regardless of the nature of that conflict. This is not a good argument against private societies, unless you want to start banning any situation that could at some point lead to a conflict of interest.
But it is very reasonable for the society to expect a basic degree of transparency from an NGO or a political party - insofar as the actions in question are meant to have public impact. It's a two-way street, to me.
Note that I'm not even entering the subject of legal obligations here. Whether or how to enforce this approach is a separate discussion (quite a few democratic constitutions do forbid political organizations of clandestine structures and membership). I'm only referring to common sense, and what feels justified.
Is it a private matter if someone held on trial is the judge's boss in a secret organization they both belong to?