Re:Max Planck Society Discontinues Agreement with Elsevier
by posterboy on Thursday December 20, 2018 @10:02AM
(#18725424)
I am a bit on the fence about the violent nature but if publishers play hard ball, I'm not sure who to blame. In the meantime, if access through libraries is revoked and if that could go on for a whi... oh right, sci-hub, but that works because of running subscriptions. What's the end-game, it goes on slowly and gradually, untill the currently invaluable material became obsolete while a substantial pre-print based reaches critical mass for all disciplines? The landscape is fractured enough despite the giants. Anyhow there's overlap with the patent problematic that you can't just unsubscribe; maybe walls need to be teared down one by one, but you don't need to torch the place (to step up your rather violent imagery).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Max Planck Society Discontinues Agreement with Elsevier
by dmitriz on Thursday December 20, 2018 @10:58AM
(#18725980)
If publishers play hardball, no researcher will ever work for them as authors, referees or editors.
Or they come down to more reasonable prices and perhaps reduce their 40% profits to ones in line with other industries?
Re:Max Planck Society Discontinues Agreement with Elsevier
by MrGunn on Thursday December 20, 2018 @12:23PM
(#18726898)
Again, Dmitri, there's plenty of reasons to criticize Elsevier without making things up. RELX doesn't break out profit by division, but the operating margin for Elsevier is around 22%, which anyone can read for themselves in their annual report.
Re:Max Planck Society Discontinues Agreement with Elsevier
by dmitriz on Thursday December 20, 2018 @01:28PM
(#18727588)
The figure of 40% appears in quite a number of sources. Do they all make things up?
Does the "operating margin" somehow refute it? Does "operating" here mean 22% after subtracting all additional (possibly luxurious or generously allocated) expenses?
No one really wants to criticise anyone and every work should be fairly rewarded. It is the unfair part that people are objecting to.
Re:Max Planck Society Discontinues Agreement with Elsevier
by Vinnl on Thursday December 20, 2018 @01:28PM
(#18727586)
Which division has the highest operating margin (and what is that margin)?
Re:Max Planck Society Discontinues Agreement with Elsevier
by posterboy on Thursday December 20, 2018 @10:34PM
(#18731238)
did you forget a zero on that figure? Where do the expenses come from if they do not pay editors, reviewers and authors? Is the discount for libraries so big that they can claim a 60% to 80% loss over a fictive idealized price?
Also, it's less the price but how the money is (not) redistributed, I thought.