Re:Improving compression at scale with Zstandard
by JyrkiAlakuijala on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @09:35PM
(#18722043)
It is a cherry picked data point, and not representative for brotli. There, facebook shows numbers with quality 0. However, when they compress for the web, they use brotli with quality 5 for dynamic content and quality 9 (or 11?) for static content.
At higher quality settings brotli wins in compression density, and particularly so with quality 11 or with short files.
Quality 0 is an irrelevant corner case of maximal compression speed, and is completely impractical for most uses.
If you plot the whole curve, brotli's density is above that of zstd's for compression speed/density -- when both algos are used with same backward reference window size.
At higher quality settings brotli wins in compression density, and particularly so with quality 11 or with short files.
Quality 0 is an irrelevant corner case of maximal compression speed, and is completely impractical for most uses.
If you plot the whole curve, brotli's density is above that of zstd's for compression speed/density -- when both algos are used with same backward reference window size.