News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google isn’t the company that we should have handed the W... by jgon on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @05:36PM (#18711249)
Wait a guy who works for a company that uses the world's most popular website (the google search homepage) to aggressively proselytize it's own browser is complaining about Windows prompting you to use Edge? For real dude?

Edit: I'll expand. You work for a company the bundled Chrome as a default install with many other toolbars and utility programs. You sell a line of computing products where Chrome is not only the default, it is literally the only browser than can be installed. Chrome is the default browser on the world's most popular OS (Android). Multiple Google properties have refused to work on other browsers and displayed a popup asking people to switch the Chrome (Inbox is the one I remember most vividly). Here's a link to people trying to figure out how to get Chrome to stop asking to be default every time it opens: https://www.tenforums.com/browsers-email/59843-how-stop-goog... As you can see it's not exactly an easy task. All of this, and probably more, and you're here talking about what Windows does? C'mon man.

Re:Google isn’t the company that we should have handed the W... by DannyBee on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:26AM (#18713269)
I am so unbelievably tired of the hacker news "you work for company x and therefore your opinion is tainted and you aren't allowed to have personal opinions" crap I don't even know where to begin. It's just another form of worthless bias being used to dismiss arguments.

It's no different than any other form of bias, even if it seems more socially acceptable here.

If you want to argue with what I actually wrote, happy to have that discussion. Otherwise, not interested, sorry.

[dead]
Re:Google isn’t the company that we should have handed the W... by tptacek on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:04AM (#18713451)
Hey. This is a pattern of argument that is explicitly forbidden by the site guidelines. Please stop asserting, overtly or implicitly, that people are making arguments because they're shills for this company or that.

Beyond that: I've read every 'DannyBee comment on HN for the past several years and I assure you he has far stronger opinions about register allocators and the LLVM development process and open source licensing than he does about people criticizing Google.

I think you owe him an apology.

Re:Google isn’t the company that we should have handed the W... by dontblink on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @06:37PM (#18711619)
What does that have to do with his point? Could you address his comment instead? "C'mon man."
Re:Google isn’t the company that we should have handed the W... by jgon on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @07:11PM (#18711838)
He doesn't have a point. He has whataboutism. So I decided to address his whataboutism by pointing out that Google is honestly even worse at what he is talking about, and thus his whataboutism is in fact invalid. So in a roundabout way I did address his "point".
Re:Google isn’t the company that we should have handed the W... by DannyBee on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:35AM (#18713311)
You certainly have an interesting perspective on what you did there.

That comment would be equally as worthwhile and useful if you had started it with some other form of bias to justify it like "Wait, a woman who is black ...."

If your comment starts with some form of "well you are an x so ...", it's probably not actually addressing anything other than your own interesting biases against people.

Or you know, just dismiss whatever you want with bias and claims of whataboutism. I guess that works too!

Despite your claim of whataboutism, i'm instead showing the author is incredibly conveniently eliding large parts of actual history in trying to make their point. You may want to argue those shouldn't matter (or make it worse). That's at least a more valid argument than you made.

I would argue if you asked most people they do in fact matter because the world is not an abstract idealist paradise.

The internet definitely never has been in the past, so saying it isn't in the future is not particular interesting.