Re:How Alexa knows “peanut butter” is one shopping-list item...
by L2R on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @04:08PM
(#18710589)
Spot on. Just a heads up, there is a decent amount of work on using convolutions to condense the initial representations and can reduce computation time equal to your max pooling. A lot of these tasks can be done via hyperparameter search over CNNs, so you can easily reach parity using a CNN-LSTM approach w/ the same number of parameters.
I also notice a lot of dismissive comments about "black box models" or the simple solutions of just parsing out whitespace. My two cents:
1. Models with hand crafted rules perform WORSE than learned representations, especially when you have an end-to-end model with pre trained embeddings. This is shown by one of the seminal papers on this model, Ma and Hovy (2016) https://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.01354.pdf.
"However, even systems that have utilized dis-tributed representations as inputs have used theseto augment, rather than replace, hand-crafted fea-tures (e.g. word spelling and capitalization pat-terns). Their performance drops rapidly when themodels solely depend on neural embeddings"
2. Human speech and human written text are messy. Having a rule for human speech will inevitably lead to a massive list of rules and exceptions to those rules.
3. This model is multi domain, meaning that you don't just need rules for one domain, but rules for multiple domains and interactions between those domains. Considering Amazon's hefty amount of data, it's much more efficient to learn these represntations though a machine learning model rather than constantly playing cat-and-mouse with keeping your hand crafted rules.