I like your mapping just about as well as the Dotsies mapping. Slightly more speckled vs angular. I wish others who are finding fault with the mapping would go down this path as well. I think they would quickly realize that one mapping is (generally speaking) about as good as another, so you might as well pick one with a good order. That's why I created that page.
http://dotsies.org/design-your-own/#iaeouvxnsfrcbqlzkjwygphm...
A couple of design values:
- vowels 1 dot seems like a good plan
- ending with s / y should be easily recognizable
- tall letters should be tall (tlbdk etc)
To learn, read one word from the top paragraph and see if it "looks" like the bottom dotsies. Then gradually try to read the paragraph without looking at the next word.
Open to improvements!