Re:"The web is considered 'public domain'"
by bigiain on Thursday November 04, 2010 @06:46PM
(#1871132)
You don't consider the offer to "make good" by donating $130 to the school of journalism to be a perfectly good first option before "belligerent counter-attack"?
Griggs was an idiot - but thats OK, there's no law against being an idiot. There _is_ a copyright law though. Griggs was offered a simple and inexpensive way to to fix the crime she committed out of her idiocy, and she chose to not take up that offer. What else should the copyright owner in a case like this do except get belligerent?
Re:"The web is considered 'public domain'"
by tbrownaw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @05:52PM
(#1870966)
> But generally we all ought to be copying stuff pretty freely.
Which we can't do under the current laws, regardless of whether we ignore people who don't understand those laws. What's the best way to get the laws fixed?
Re:"The web is considered 'public domain'"
by gloob on Thursday November 04, 2010 @09:16PM
(#1871588)
What's the best way to get the laws fixed?
"Convince everyone to ignore them" seems like a reasonable first step.
Re:"The web is considered 'public domain'"
by tomjen3 on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:37AM
(#1872889)
Well in that case, mission accomplished.
Re:"The web is considered 'public domain'"
by techiferous on Thursday November 04, 2010 @10:19PM
(#1871728)
Regardless of copyright philosophy, it's more about honoring the expectations of each party in the business transaction. The agreement was that they could publish the article once but not republish. Regardless of the law, breaching that mutually-agreed expectation was bound to cause problems.
Everyone is provoked to a belligerent counter-attack: demand restitution! lawyer-up! sue! But this only consolidates the underlying problem. It is just the wrongness of the system popping up in a different place. The way forward is less restrictions, less legal action, not more aggressive enforcement for everyone.
If someone plagiarises something, and then excuses themself with a pack of bumptious squirmy nonsense, they can be ridiculed. But generally we all ought to be copying stuff pretty freely.