News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by chrisco255 on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:37AM (#18697090)
In my experience, few people are NOT trapped in a filter bubble. If you've ever moved from a conservative area to a liberal area of the country, or vice versa, you'll feel this in your interactions with people. In modern politics, it's far more difficult to find people who are able to constructively engage with both sides than it is to find blatant partisans. Simple test for this is to ask some one to describe the positions of the other party and why they feel the way they do without using any disparaging or cynical terms. Fun experiment, I invite you to try it.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by MrQuincle on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:28AM (#18697640)
Your approach sounds like a confrontational approach. In "The culture map" it is described that the US culture is far less confrontational than e.g. France. It might be difficult to engage in a discussion without disclaimers such as "let me play devil's advocate". As in this book is explained, an American was wondering why the French at the dinner table were laughing together after a heated discussion on a topic short before. A discussion is not a personal attack. However, in the US it is quicker felt this way.

Hence, that people are not trapped in filter bubbles should not be countered by an argument based on a personal confrontational approach about how constructively they engage in political discussions.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by lanevorockz on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:09AM (#18697769)
French are not heavy users of social media. It is social media and agenda driven journalism that creates the polarisation.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by sharemywin on Monday December 17, 2018 @08:34AM (#18698810)
That's not what causes polarization. Those just speed it up and amplify it.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by barrow-rider on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:25PM (#18700388)
While social media usage is lower in France[1], it's laughable to say that it's not a force. Nor is agenda & social-media driven journalism less of a thing, it's just mitigated by government fairness doctrines[2] -- but certainly still there.

Hell, you can make a prima facie argument that this is totally true just by looking at the massive riots happening all across France.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/284435/france-social-net...

[2] https://www.extradigital.co.uk/articles/social-media/social-...

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by sien on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:59AM (#18697177)
You've described an 'Ideological Turing Test' :

https://www.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/the_ideological.htm...

It's a fun thing to try and do.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by elliekelly on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:09AM (#18699350)
> If someone can correctly explain a position but continue to disagree with it, that position is less likely to be correct. And if ability to correctly explain a position leads almost automatically to agreement with it, that position is more likely to be correct.

Wow, really interesting. Thanks for sharing!

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by lazyasciiart on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:21AM (#18697813)
I'm not sure that has any bearing on whether they are "trapped in a filter bubble". It is quite possible to very deeply understand the motivations and thoughts of a group and still be blatantly disparaging - ask a historian, for instance.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by comicjk on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:12AM (#18698987)
Likewise, it's easy to read strongly liberal/conservative takes on the news without being convinced by them. They are pitched to an audience with very different priors, and often are not even trying to convince anyone else.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by chrisco255 on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:39AM (#18697881)
Let's say you have a historian who believes that historical group X were terrible human beings. How likely do you suppose that this historian would be open to new information that shed new light on group X, with some positive and possibly redemptive qualities?

I reckon, based on my understanding of human nature, that historian would take a while to come around, if they ever revised their perspective at all.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by watwut on Monday December 17, 2018 @07:33AM (#18698546)
> Let's say you have a historian who believes that historical group X were terrible human beings. How likely do you suppose that this historian would be open to new information that shed new light on group X, with some positive and possibly redemptive qualities?

Pretty much all historians face that whenever analyzing WWII. Answer is partly in historians not making direct moral judgement in their historical work. The goal is not to decide whether people were "good" or "bad". That is for philosophers and fiction writers.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by bilbo0s on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:25AM (#18699069)
>How likely do you suppose that this historian would be open to new information...

New "information", yeah, not very likely at all.

New "evidence", very likely indeed.

"Evidence", can be investigated for veracity. Information, is no better than you and I sitting around making up stuff.

I think that's a subtle but important distinction that I think a lot of people don't understand about the work of a historian. You have plenty of people who wrote down a story about Agincourt for instance. Plenty of people will still tell you some story about Agincourt today. But only a very, very, few of those stories are consistent with the evidence. For example:

----

Hmm, there are a shit ton of arrow heads at Agincourt.

Wow! They're all laying in EXACTLY the distribution that long dead historian X indicated given his account of the battle.

Hmm. None of them are where long dead historian Y indicated given her account of the battle.

----

You analyze historical site after historical site, and after a while, you figure out that the accounts of long dead historian X nearly always align closely with the physical historical evidence. So... yeah... naturally after a while, over the hundreds of years that pass, more and more historians start believing long dead historian X rather than long dead historian Y.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by lazyasciiart on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:22PM (#18701843)
I'm not sure that has anything to do with filter bubbles either. In fact, it seems to be an argument that it doesn't matter what kind of news and information gets presented to people, even if everyone gets the same news feed they'll keep their existing opinions.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by dchichkov on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:53AM (#18697150)
Use of disparaging terms is arguably caused by the need to belong to local community. That is, if you don't want to be outsider, you have to use "appropriate" language and show "correct" values (on climate change, abortion, etc).

So arguably it is more of a local, group identity effect, like being a fun of a local sports team, than a true bubble / filter effect.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by chrisco255 on Monday December 17, 2018 @01:24AM (#18697253)
Group identities are the best way to create filter bubbles.

Once you've aligned yourself with a group, you're less likely to be swayed by "outsiders". You'll resist, even if subconsciously, any suggestion which opposes your team's view, because you'll begin to develop an identity around those viewpoints. Few people are well-practiced at challenging their own identities.

Check out this excellent essay by PG, "Keep Your Identity Small", for a better description of this phenomenon: http://paulgraham.com/identity.html

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by dchichkov on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @12:32PM (#18708511)
Thank you. It is of an excellent quality.

I would add, a modern definition of a "humanist", which includes "scientist" in its core might be a good core for a modern minimalistic identity.

And thank you again, for bringing this to my attention. I'm going to put it into my AGI research notebook ;)

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by mirimir on Monday December 17, 2018 @08:24AM (#18698766)
I've always hated shaving. And I also hate trimming beards. When I was working in meatspace, I just kept my head and face at about 3-5 mm. But now, I'm just Mr Natural.

So now, among my friends and their families, I'm just another old hippie. But in conservative areas, I can easily pass as Duck Dynasty :) Especially if I'm wearing my NRA hat ;)

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:38AM (#18699173)
>Simple test for this is to ask some one to describe the positions of the other party and why they feel the way they do without using any disparaging or cynical terms

That doesn't work because liberals are unable to understand and empathize with conservative views. They lack the same fundamental values, and so they are unable to see conservative views as being within a set of values that are different from their own. Instead they see conservative views as being contrary to values, period. Liberals being asked to answer a survey the way they think a conservative would will answer agree/disagree questions like "one of the worst things a person could do is hurt a defenseless animal" with disagree, but actual conservatives say agree. On the other hand, conservatives are able to accurately answer the same survey as a liberal would. Moderates are able to answer accurately as either a liberal or a conservative.

https://theindependentwhig.com/haidt-passages/haidt/conserva...

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by AlphaSite on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:14AM (#18699383)
Tbh my observation is both sides demonise each other. ‘Abortion is murder’ being one example of the inverse.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:26AM (#18699479)
Both sides do demonize each other, that's not the question. The question is if they understand each other. Abortion is a perfect example. Conservatives understand the liberal position, that a woman's "right" to an abortion is more important than a fetus's "right" to live. Obviously they disagree, and obviously they consider the other view abhorrent. But they understand what that view is.

On other other hand, liberals overwhelmingly do not understand conservative positions. Sticking with the same issue of abortion, most liberals say conservatives oppose abortion because they hate women and want to control their bodies. This despite the fact that the majority of people opposed to abortion are women. They simply believe the reverse of what I stated above: that the fetus's "right" to live is more important than the woman's "right" to have an abortion.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by amanaplanacanal on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:53PM (#18701595)
I'm torn on this. The liberal understanding of this is not entirely wrong. The evidence is that if you look at the big pro-life groups, they are not just anti abortion, they are also anti birth control. So it is not entirely irrational for liberals to think the way they do about this. Perhaps the folks who are both pro-life AND pro birth control need to up their game?

edit: I would bet that this is because Roman Catholics provide most of the funding for the big pro-life groups.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:06PM (#18701709)
>The liberal understanding of this is not entirely wrong

Yes, it is.

>The evidence is that if you look at the big pro-life groups, they are not just anti abortion, they are also anti birth control.

That is incorrect, and a good example of the bubbles being real. You are just looking at church opposition because that's what the media likes to focus on showing. And it would not make the liberal idea of the conservative view correct even if it were true. Christians who oppose birth control do so because they value the traditions of their culture, not because they hate women. Again, most of them are women. And many of the people who are portrayed as "opposing birth control" actually just oppose having their tax money used to pay for other people's birth control, which is not the same thing.

>So it is not entirely irrational for liberals to think the way they do about this.

It isn't irrational. Being wrong is not the same as being irrational.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by ArchTypical on Monday December 17, 2018 @05:01PM (#18702642)
>The liberal understanding of this is not entirely wrong >Yes, it is.

No, it's not ENTIRELY wrong.

https://www.quora.com/Does-the-pro-life-movement-consider-co...

> It isn't irrational. Being wrong is not the same as being irrational.

Rational: based on or in accordance with reason or logic.

Your argumentative tone is not compelling and you fail to demonstrate your position within some very constrained topics. Perhaps you will reconsider some of these ideas.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @05:29PM (#18702852)
>No, it's not ENTIRELY wrong.

Your link does not support your belief that it is in some way partially correct. The catholic church is not a pro-life group. They pre-date the very idea of a pro-life group by many centuries. The largest pro-life group that random person lists does not have a position on birth control. So this does not support the notion that pro-life equals anti-birth control. But again, even if pro-life did equal anti-birth control that would not support the belief that pro-life people are pro-life because they hate women.

In case you missed in the post you are replying to: "And it would not make the liberal idea of the conservative view correct even if it were true. Christians who oppose birth control do so because they value the traditions of their culture, not because they hate women." Even if every single person who opposes abortion also opposed birth control, that would not make the belief that those people oppose abortion because they hate women correct. Opposing birth control is not hating women any more than opposing abortion is. Consider the opposite incorrect belief: "liberals hate babies, that's why they are pro-abortion". Now would you think "liberals also support birth control, so that proves it is because they hate babies" is good support for that belief? Neither supporting abortion nor supporting birth control can be equated to hating babies, just as neither opposing abortion nor opposing birth control can be equated to hating women.

>Rational: based on or in accordance with reason or logic

Yes? The four humors theory of health and medicine was based on reason and logic. It was also wrong. You can have a rational belief based on incomplete or incorrect data.

>Your argumentative tone is not compelling

Please don't assume a "tone" for someone. It does not further discussion.

>Perhaps you will reconsider some of these ideas.

I have. And in light of the lack of contradictory evidence, my views did not change this time.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by ArchTypical on Monday December 17, 2018 @07:09PM (#18703477)
> Your link does not support your belief that it is in some way partially correct.

Not my belief. I have evidence, so it's what I know, since previously I did not know. I found your arguments compelling and looked it up.

> In case you missed in the post you are replying to:

Nope. You decided to ignore a statement you agreed with for another you wanted to attack.

The largest pro life groups (as a body made up of pie slices) does evidently (ie have evidence) that supports:

> they are not just anti abortion, they are also anti birth control

Which is what was being referenced by at least a partial correctness, since it was a following statement. Not sure who you're trying to fool.

> Yes? The four humors theory of health and medicine was based on reason and logic. It was also wrong

Wrong is a matter of evidence. For the time, it was right as right can be. That's how science works and is in accordance with rationality. Proving a theorem, does not mean that bringing it up as a theorem was/is wrong. Over time, changes in knowledge are part of the process.

Good luck with your religious convictions to these issues.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @07:47PM (#18703663)
>I have evidence

Then why not present it? Until you establish it is fact, then yes it is your belief.

>You decided to ignore a statement you agreed with for another you wanted to attack.

I have no idea what you mean.

>The largest pro life groups (as a body made up of pie slices) does evidently (ie have evidence) that supports

The link you provided says otherwise. It very clearly shows the largest pro-life group has no position on birth control.

>Which is what was being referenced by at least a partial correctness

That does not make logical sense. The statement "conservatives support abortion because they hate women and want to control their bodies" is not proven to be partially correct even if you believe that all conservatives oppose birth control. Opposing birth control is not hating women.

>For the time, it was right as right can be

No it was not. Incorrect isn't correct if you simply don't know any better.

>Good luck with your religious convictions to these issues.

I find it interesting that you ignore what I say, try to attribute what I say to malice, claim your belief is objective fact, and still suggest that I am the one with religious conviction here. "Conservatives hate women because I say they do" is not fact, no matter how many times you repeat it.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by amanaplanacanal on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:21PM (#18701825)
Can you me to pro-life groups that are also pro-birth control? I admit I haven't looked recently, but the last time I did I could not find any.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by jki275 on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:27PM (#18701873)
Being against birth control is a very specific thing to the Catholic church. Almost no one else subscribes to that belief, including nearly all religious and non-religious groups in north america.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:48PM (#18702541)
I couldn't name a pro-life group period. I know a lot of churches are pro-life, but they are not pro-life groups any more than they are anti-theft groups.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by gerbilly on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:24PM (#18700385)
> That doesn't work because liberals are unable to understand and empathize with conservative views.

Actually conservatives and liberals do share a lot of values. Let's call this the foundational set V.

Conservatives go on to add additional values to the set V: mostly concerns for purity, respect for authority and a heightened concern for security. Let's call this set A.

Conservatives could then easily predict the answers of liberals because they are both based on V, but it's not symmetrical, because conservatives are working from a bigger set of values V+A.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:55PM (#18701613)
>Actually conservatives and liberals do share a lot of values

They share two or three values: care and fairness for sure, and maybe liberty (not necessarily a value held by either group, but one held by some subset of both groups). That doesn't contradict my statement that liberals are unable to understand and empathize with conservative views. Views are based on values. Lacking the values that create the view makes it very hard to understand the view.

>Conservatives go on to add additional values to the set V

Precisely, they add loyalty, authority and sanctity. Liberals do not have these values, often even viewing them as evil. And so they do not understand the views based on those values. Conservatives do have the values liberals do, and so they can understand the views based on those values.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by repolfx on Monday December 17, 2018 @01:22PM (#18700821)
Whilst that's one way to phrase it, the underlying differences are deeper and more to do with perception of the span of human nature.

For instance the apparent love of conservatives for 'respect for authority' is not actually respect for authority (why would they be so against big government if that were the case?) nor particular to conservatives, but rather, a preference for systems and formalised power structures over loose, informally specified power structures. One can observe that people with liberal views often have tremendous respect for certain types of unstructured authority, in particular, academics.

The book "A Conflict Of Visions" provides an alternative explanation for this apparent discovery that liberals cannot understand conservatives but not vice-versa. Conservatives see disagreement with their world view as naivety, but liberals see disagreement with their world view as the result of an evil or malign nature. The latter view leads to a belief that attempting to understand such a perspective is itself immoral behaviour, as you might be legitimising it, or alternatively, might be tempted to the dark side by mere exposure to the ideas themselves.

This is why you see so much no-platforming and general censorship coming from people with particular world views: they believe that conservative ideas work like some sort of infectious disease. Conservatives don't think that way about liberal views.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by gerbilly on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:51PM (#18701577)
Ok, let me tweak my list of additional conservative values then: heightened concern for purity, intolerance of ambiguity and a heightened concern for security.

NOTE: I am not conservative, so take that for what it's worth.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @05:08PM (#18702695)
>For instance the apparent love of conservatives for 'respect for authority' is not actually respect for authority (why would they be so against big government if that were the case?)

Because authority is not the only value they hold, it is just one of six values. Overreaching authority will naturally conflict with those other values, particularly liberty. This is also complicated by the fact that libertarians tend to be lumped into the category of conservatives in the US, when libertarians have little in common with conservatives and overwhelmingly base their moral foundations entirely on liberty. Libertarians don't have respect for authority, conservatives do. But if you call libertarians conservatives, that will make things look weird.

>One can observe that people with liberal views often have tremendous respect for certain types of unstructured authority, in particular, academics.

I can not observe that at all. Quite the contrary, I find overwhelmingly that liberals do not respect authority in any form. Academics are not respected by liberals, they are constantly attacked and vilified for publishing facts that liberals don't like. Liberals will point to an academic that agrees with them to bolster their argument, but they don't actually respect academics, as they have nothing but disdain for an academic that disagrees with them. Look at how James Watson has been treated by liberals, I don't see a lot of respect there. If they had respect for academic authority, they would actually consider what is said, instead of assuming the person saying it is evil and calling them evil.

>The book "A Conflict Of Visions" provides an alternative explanation for this apparent discovery

I'm not sure that's an alternative explanation, it seems like the same explanation. Haidt notes the same thing, that liberals view conservatives as evil because the underlying values conservatives hold are not values to liberals. While conservatives see liberals as ignorant or stupid, because they incorrectly assume liberals are using the same underlying values to come to conclusions about issues and so they must be ignorant of some fact or making an error of reasoning.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by dyeje on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:44AM (#18699203)
Can you provide the actual study? I find this anecdote hard to believe.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by agsdfgsd on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:12AM (#18699367)
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by beobab on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:48AM (#18697698)
I've found that it's important to discover whether the other party understands the word "argument" to mean "disagreement" or "logical reasoning".

If you don't agree on basic word meaning, then it's hard to hold a rational conversation.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by new299 on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:05AM (#18697758)
The word can be used in both ways, depending on the context?
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by jonathanstrange on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:16AM (#18698249)
Yes. It's a peculiarity of the English language.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by godelski on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:46AM (#18697121)
It is always strange to me how this happens. You are exactly right in asking how one describes the other party. People are really similar, just with different beliefs.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by snaky on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:12AM (#18697584)
Speaking of that,

> We provide a set of results that, given a set of individuals' belief systems, allow a systematic determination of which topics will reach a consensus, and which topics will disagreement in arise.

https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.05138

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by gammateam on Monday December 17, 2018 @04:21AM (#18697815)
Every time your parents or grandparents say something insensitive about a group of people, I always think about how it is currently socially acceptable to think of the other party as irreconcilable dangerous mentally unstable people

This kind of thought was acceptable and comforting to your parents about people that now contribute greatly to society

Everyone is doing it across the party line right now and it is ridiculous and they dont know that people in the other party are taking the exact same approach

Almost no party and no issue is based on the exact opposite reasoning for not agreeing

So that means people are a lot more reconcilable than some party line quip would suggest

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by watwut on Monday December 17, 2018 @01:44AM (#18697310)
The moment you framed it as two sides you pushed people toward creating one overreaching characterization for both sides. It is effectively asking for partizan position, because no other is possible.

The other question is, what if the cynical disparaging term is factually correct one for portions of each party?

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by Applejinx on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:06AM (#18698219)
And of course 'both sides' is itself a filter bubble reducing analysis to one particularly rigid point of view…
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by chrisco255 on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:47AM (#18699642)
Well if someone is even able to describe the other side in a nuanced way, breaking down some of the points of view of the various factions that make up each side...I would say they're half way there.

A cynical, disparaging term is opinion, not fact. So you can't be "factually correct" when evaluating someone's opinion.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by watwut on Monday December 17, 2018 @02:30PM (#18701412)
A lot of disparaging comments express real things. Coward, racist, flip floper, unprincipled. These exists and are also disparaging.

I think that if you start with assumption of two sides and your question forces the person to be in one, then you already stopped being nuanced. Because the other side are those whose views are as far from mine as possible by definition.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by chrisco255 on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @12:09AM (#18704661)
I think insults definitely have utility. They're persuasive tools that cut through cruft...but they're also opinions. It's not a "fact" that someone is being cowardly, for example...that's just an observational opinion. From a certain point of view, someone can seem like a coward and from another point of view they can seem heroic. These are perceptual things...so they're not facts.
Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by watwut on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @04:45PM (#18720020)
How is that not a possible fact? And also, if you exclude observational opinions, then it is impossible to full fill your "describe the other side" demand. Because when you ask someone to describe someone else, you are literally asking for a bunch of observational opinions.

Disparaging and insult is not really the same. To go to clear extreme, I can be disparaging of Goring or Himmler without going out of my way of being insulting. Just by telling the truth about what they did, believed and who they were.

Re:Few people are actually trapped in filter bubbles. Why do... by jonathanstrange on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:15AM (#18698247)
You're from the US, right?

What you describe seems to be the default behaviour of humans on the one hand, and the effect of political polarization in the US on the other hand. Neither of those phenomena are necessarily based on filter bubbles.