News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UX Bloat Nonsense by fauigerzigerk on Thursday November 04, 2010 @11:51AM (#1869375)
No, adverts are almost always irrelevant for almost everybody. They are a necessary (and sometimes unnecessary) evil. Most of us don't look for something to buy all the time. When I read my mail or a blog or whatever, that huge burger and coke ad right in the middle of the screen is an irrelevant distraction.

When I have to watch that very same 30 second Hoodie Footie Pajamagram - the perfect way to snuggle up - segment before each and every 3m news video on CNBC it's a torture for my brain.

I wish more sites gave me a reasonable way to buy myself freedom from that "highly relevant" bloat.

[Edit] As a service provider, I appreciate the convenient excuse you provide for torturing my users ;-)

Re:UX Bloat Nonsense by bradleyjoyce on Thursday November 04, 2010 @12:29PM (#1869578)
I think Google's billions in revenue and profits would beg to differ with you. (ads on google search results are generally highly relevant and get clicked a lot)

you are right, however, if the people you are generalizing for are HN folks, and websites other than Google.

Re:UX Bloat Nonsense by fauigerzigerk on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:04PM (#1869742)
Revenue and relevance is not quite the same. A 1% clickthrough rate would lead to great revenue for all concerned, but it still means I'm annoying 99% of my users (or one user 99% of the time).

Of course, not all non-clickers would be terribly annoyed, but many of the clickers might still be annoyed by the distraction even though the ad was relevant enough to click on.