News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by dragonwriter on Saturday December 15, 2018 @06:16PM (#18690890)
> The United States excels at sigint and aerial/orbital recon, but the Russians have been top-notch at humint for a long time.

Maybe, but there's also an inherent counterintelligence asymetry between a liberal democracy and a totalitarian police state (which is why in a liberal democracy, the counterintelligence services are often trying to simulate a totalitarian police state.)

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by JamesBarney on Saturday December 15, 2018 @07:10PM (#18691033)
I think the U.S. is just an especially easy place to send a deep cover agent.

It has a high standard of living so it's easier to recruit someone to be willing to live here for long periods of time.

It's not uncommon for someone to have a social circle made up entirely of people they've only known a few years. This seems to be much less the case in other places in the world, especially Russia.

It's much more culturally heterogenous so it's easier for someone to blend in.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by travmatt on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:54PM (#18691347)
That probably contributes, but that can’t be the entire story. A previous post on HN discussed the means by which the soviets excelled at identifying CIA agents working under diplomatic cover - it turns out that American tradecraft was hardly as great as we believed - their sloppiness meant that CIA agents under diplomatic cover had unique payscales, tour lengths, working hours, socialization habits, and many other attributes that allowed their covers to be blown. If you can uncover the handlers by their sloppy tradecraft, surveilling and rolling up their assets isn’t going to be that hard - the lack of constitutionally guaranteed protections just meant that those networks could be rooted out quickly once uncovered, but it didn’t necessarily have to contribute towards their discovery.
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by MediumD on Saturday December 15, 2018 @09:36PM (#18691458)
Do you have a link? Would love to read about that
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by travmatt on Saturday December 15, 2018 @11:15PM (#18691708)
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by whatshisface on Saturday December 15, 2018 @06:31PM (#18690943)
>Maybe, but there's also an inherent counterintelligence asymetry between a liberal democracy and a totalitarian police state

You could just as easily argue it in the opposite direction, it is much easier to co-opt the corrupt Russian government than it is to co-opt the less corrupt American government. An individual corrupt unaccountable person of interest in a totalitarian police state is far more valuable than an individual corrupt person of interest that is being watched like a hawk by the public in a liberal democracy.

I think a much more reasonable explanation for why government organizations are always trying to become more totalitarian is simply that the officials would rather have more power than less power. The only difference between here and there are the checks placed on them to limit what they can do.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by dragonwriter on Saturday December 15, 2018 @07:03PM (#18691018)
> You could just as easily argue it in the opposite direction, it is much easier to co-opt the corrupt Russian government than it is to co-opt the less corrupt American government

Note that I was referring to the explanation of the relative success of US vs. Soviet placement/detection of agents (from context, intelligence officers, not assets, though “agent” can mean either); Russia’s current government and the Soviet government aren't the same thing.

> I think a much more reasonable explanation for why government organizations are always trying to become more totalitarian

That's not the effect I was explaining or, even, at that level of generality, one I'd agree exists.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by lsc on Saturday December 15, 2018 @07:22PM (#18691076)
>it is much easier to co-opt the corrupt Russian government than it is to co-opt the less corrupt American government.

Can you give a cold war example of America effecting who ran russia that is as dramatic as the Trump story in the other direction?

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by pessimizer on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:10PM (#18691207)
There's no evidence that Russia had any significant effect on who runs the US, even if you accept all of the claimed attempts as true, whereas it's universally accepted and documented that the US got Yeltsin elected: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/aug/03/spinning-hilla...
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by lsc on Saturday December 15, 2018 @09:12PM (#18691393)
Hey, thanks for the link, I wasn't aware of the US involvement with the election of Yeltsin. That's especially interesting, as Yeltsin essentially dissolved the USSR.

There is a long history of foreign interventions in elections being catastrophic; I recently read Herman's "1917: Lenin, Wilson, and the Birth of the New World Disorder" - and he claims that there is pretty solid evidence that Lenin was bankrolled by Germany in very impactful ways.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by adventured on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:42PM (#18691316)
I'm fairly certain the thousands of dollars Russia spent on Google and Facebook ads, overwhelmed the $1.2 billion that was spent in total on the Clinton election campaign.
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by polkapolka on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:56PM (#18691354)
The ads are a red herring (and uncomfortably visible for both parties).

The real activity was on Facebook groups, viralizing anti-immigration and far-left news, controling the narritive on 4chan pol and /r/the_donald, and botted up - and downvote brigades.

It was so blatant it was visible to a non-expert on information warfare like me.

The people doing this probably got paid about as much as a paid advertisement.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by lsc on Saturday December 15, 2018 @09:56PM (#18691510)
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/13/us/politics/butina-guilty...

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/11/wikilea...

I suspect we will see more of this sort of thing as the investigation continues, but of course, the investigation isn't over yet. My point is just that it was a lot more than 4chan and facebook.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by willholloway on Sunday December 16, 2018 @12:23AM (#18691868)
More than 62 million Americans voted for Donald Trump, maybe they were the ones up voting stories on 4chan and Reddit because they agree with him.
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by scottlocklin on Saturday December 15, 2018 @10:11PM (#18691553)
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by dragonwriter on Saturday December 15, 2018 @11:06PM (#18691686)
> > Can you give a cold war example of America effecting who ran russia that is as dramatic as the Trump story in the other direction?

> Yelzin.

That's...not a Cold War example.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by scottlocklin on Sunday December 16, 2018 @07:54AM (#18692870)
And it wasn't called "Russia" during the cold war; I interpolated.

The US interfering in the 1996 Russian election to install 'our guy' stands as a preposterous, ridiculous overt interference with Russian politics on a scale which the Russians can never hope to achieve.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by lsc on Sunday December 16, 2018 @06:01PM (#18695790)
What I find super interesting is that some people in the USA seem to think that evidence that the US has attacked the elections of the USSR and Russia in the past means that we somehow shouldn't fight when the reverse happens. I mean, if you accept that we got Yeltsin elected, well, in a real way, we dissolved the USSR, making Russia dramatically less powerful. (And yes, I agree that's dramatically more severe than anything Trump has done so far.)

I am not going to vote for any politician who thinks allowing the same sort of thing to happen to the USA is in any way okay.

(I mean, from a completely neutral sense, I get what they are saying... but I'm not completely neutral; I don't think any of us are. Leaving aside that I think you can make a reasonable argument that the USSR was, even for those who lived there, a bad thing, (though I'm obviously biased on that point.) I do think it's reasonable to expect your political leaders to take steps to prevent your country from being taken over by a foreign power.)

Edit: neutrality and clarity

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by scottlocklin on Monday December 17, 2018 @08:16PM (#18703803)
You have an interesting parser.

How do you feel about the interference of Israel, Saudi Arabia and China in US elections? Because they've certainly subverted US democracy a lot more than the integral of all Russian/Soviet interference with US elections over all time (China being a very junior partner, but still pretty obviously doing so in ways the Russians don't). Shucks, any one of them interfered more in the last election more than the Russians ever have.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by lsc on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:32PM (#18704336)
On this, we disagree about the evidence.

It appears that there is a federal investigator on the case, so I suggest we watch what comes of that.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by scottlocklin on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @10:30AM (#18707130)
Well, the countries I mention above do seem to have subverted elections in a rather more threatening way; unlike those sinister Russians, they seem to have left rather more evidence, and have subverted democracy so effectively there will never be a federal investigator on the case.
Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by dragonwriter on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:39AM (#18697664)
> And it wasn't called "Russia" during the cold war

Russia was called “Russia” during the Cold War (for that matter, in the West, informally, so, frequently, was the Soviet Union.)

> The US interfering in the 1996 Russian election to install 'our guy'

“Our guy” had been installed in the Russian Presidency long before he became our guy, while the Russian Federation was still part of the USSR. Whatever interference happened in ’96 wasn't to install anything.

> overt interference with Russian politics on a scale which the Russians can never hope to achieve.

Well, yeah, overt interference, to even have a hope of not being wildly counterproductive, requires establishing a certain level of goodwill with the target population.

There said, the recent Russian covert (though not so much as to withstand much scrutiny) intervention in Western (not merely US) politics has been on a broader scale, and more successful at driving outcomes, than anything either side did, during or after the Cold War, in the 20th Century.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by scottlocklin on Monday December 17, 2018 @08:13PM (#18703787)
You're missing out on something: it wasn't considered overt to the Russian people at the time. We subverted Russian democracy. This is all completely documented and non controversial.

Unlike the conspiracy theory that $20k in allegedly Russian purchased FB ads (or whatever the insane idea is this week) is why a reality TV star won the presidency.

Re:How the CIA Trains Spies to Hide in Plain Sight by lsc on Saturday December 15, 2018 @10:22PM (#18691591)
So, I don't really mind getting downvoted for asking questions that make me look ignorant, as I was in this case.

But when someone else answers the question, (read the rest of the thread) there's no need to answer it again.