Re:UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for El...
by JumpCrisscross on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:08PM
(#18685753)
> this tactic actually empowers Elsevier
Power and profits are closely entangled. UCLA is extracting better pricing from Elsevier's weakened position as result of open-access competition.
> it's hard to imagine anyone at Elsevier falling for this bluff
What makes you think it was a bluff? When one threatens defection, one doesn't want to defect. That's why the defection is initially threatened, not acted upon.
It's hard to imagine anyone at Elsevier falling for this bluff. They probably came in with a 40% increase knowing they'd only get 20%. After the letter, they drop the increase to 20%, then everyone claims victory and goes home.
But each round in which the OA card is played makes the bluff that much less credible.