Re:Ask HN: Is PHP/MySQL Still Practical for Building Web App...
by Loic on Thursday November 04, 2010 @03:58AM
(#1868102)
Maybe the best answer. I would just add, that if you need to integrate with a special system like an already existing business application, just be sure to have a supported set of libraries to access it from within your web application. This is the only constraint that would make me discriminate a language against another outside of the very good points of Tam.
Re:Ask HN: Is PHP/MySQL Still Practical for Building Web App...
by ulf on Thursday November 04, 2010 @10:33AM
(#1869016)
"It doesn't matter if you build your app in php, ruby, python, asp or whatever, if you're a good coder you will produce good secure code, if you suck, so will your code."
Can we please link to this in every new language discussion/flamewar?
Re:Ask HN: Is PHP/MySQL Still Practical for Building Web App...
by Ramone on Thursday November 04, 2010 @07:23AM
(#1868432)
Isn't this the opposite of "pick the right tool for the job"? Building with whatever you're most comfortable seems to be a superficial reason. Different platforms/languages have real diversity in their strengths and weaknesses.
Re:Ask HN: Is PHP/MySQL Still Practical for Building Web App...
by _b8r0 on Thursday November 04, 2010 @07:57AM
(#1868502)
You raise a valid point if you're putting up a shelf. But if you're programming then you'll be at a disadvantage if you're not familiar with the tools at hand. Even a designer is going to suffer if they're made to use the Gimp when they're used to Photoshop, not because Gimp is or isn't a good tool but because the interaction is different.
Switching from Lightroom to Aperture I've noticed substantial differences in my photography, and I'm not a very good photographer. I'm considering switching back to Lightroom - I'm sure Aperture's great, but the learning curve is harder than switching from Vim to Emacs.
Re:Ask HN: Is PHP/MySQL Still Practical for Building Web App...
by blparker on Sunday November 07, 2010 @11:49AM
(#1879698)
I agree with this to a point. You should produce code in whatever language you are most proficient/comfortable with, pending that language is suitable for the domain in which you are producing code in. I wouldn't want to try to produce a web application in Assembly.NET, nor would I want to develop a low level component in Ruby. Depending on the domain, language becomes a bigger issue, which may result in you not having the ability to be language agnostic. But, in the overall sense, I do agree with what you're saying.
Re:Ask HN: Is PHP/MySQL Still Practical for Building Web App...
by thinkingeric on Thursday November 04, 2010 @07:22AM
(#1868429)
Build in whatever the people who are going to maintain it after you've moved on are comfortable with .... if you still bear some responsibility at that point.
Re:Ask HN: Is PHP/MySQL Still Practical for Building Web App...
by xtho on Thursday November 04, 2010 @04:55AM
(#1868203)
There still is the question of how much time you're willing to spend to hunt down bugs in the interpreter/standard library/framework or to work around certain idiosyncracies that once upon a time might have looked like a cool idea. Will a "good coder" tolerate more or less such wtf moments?
So build in whatever you're most comfortable with and don't pick a language because of a superficial reason.