News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by gameswithgo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:08AM (#18671708)
The Koch brothers are amazing. Cars are bigger and heavier than ever, almost everyone has a huge truck in Austin, TX and usually an SUV if not that. They all have more power than ever. But they want to craft a narrative that Obama has been foolishly limiting our choice of cars with efficiency standards.

There are certainly lots of regulations that make cars more expensive than they need to be but I don't think MPG standards are one of the first order cases.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by assblaster on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:38AM (#18671859)
The Ford F-150 now has an aluminum body, and uses a turbocharged V6 instead of regular V8 to generate torque, and it does a good job of it.

Even so, the actual gas mileage owners get is lower than advertised, but still higher than a decade ago.

The increased fuel efficiency standards have actually lead to higher costs of vehicle development to lighten the car and make the engine do more with less.

Your lamenting the surge in trucks and SUV ownership is ironic since the increase is actually a direct result of the newer mileage standards: if trucks are now rated similar to where cars were rated 15 years ago, then why not go for the more utilitarian vehicle?

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by mtw on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:37AM (#18672185)
There's really no reason why most people in Texas commute with a truck, unless you are in construction/renovation.

If you follow the logic "go for the more utilitarian vehicle", then why not then commute with a semi trailer truck, after all these have a higher point of view, can haul more stuff. Or why not commute with a mining dump truck, it's got a practical bed and loads of space.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by S_A_P on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:41AM (#18672572)
I like in Houston. Yes there are plenty of trucks and many people driving them “unnecessarily” whatever that means. But I have worked in the northeast, mid west and west coast. Despite what you may want to believe, there are not that many more trucks in Texas than elsewhere. The F-150 would not be the best selling vehicle in the US if only Texans bought them. I personally can’t daily drive a truck because I like sportier vehicles. But I can’t be mad at someone who chooses to. They’re roomy, convenient when buying large items and as of late not earth destroying bro dozers that they seem to have a reputation for in some circles. If we truly want to make progress towards less oil dependence and cleaner vehicles then we have to get off this tribal greenies vs MAGAs nonsense that really only serves to entrench two sides. I’m somewhat interested in the auto industry, I like cars. I love old muscle cars that get 10 mpg and have horrible emissions. I also would love to own a Tesla. I would like to see future cars more in line with a model S or model X than the gas swilling muscle car. I think that the left thinks that mandates are the only way to get there. That may be partially true but I also think that mandates are pushing opposing goals. Cars have to be safer so you build heavier larger cars. That requires more horsepower so we need larger engines or forced induction. Setting a deadline for mpg and emissions is only going to make cars very expensive. Electric cars are not going to cover all use cases and there is a real problem of lithium availability and battery capacity. There have been great strides to solving these issues but it isn’t there yet. As other comments have said, passenger cars and trucks are low on the list of polluters compared to planes, semis, trains, cargo ships. Believe it or not, I think the folks in the auto industry do want to make cleaner more efficient cars and trucks, but they also are in a business where a misstep can bankrupt the company so bold moves are not on the road map.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by jefurii on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:00PM (#18673842)
> Believe it or not, I think the folks in the auto industry do want to make cleaner more efficient cars and trucks, but they also are in a business where a misstep can bankrupt the company so bold moves are not on the road map.

Wouldn't legislation that requires cleaner and more efficient vehicles level the playing field? If all companies had to do it then it wouldn't be a competitive liability.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by squish78 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:28AM (#18672491)
I work in an office job. Here are some of my reasons for owning a pickup truck, yet not a mining dump truck.

- I volunteer at a community garden and move mulch/plants/soil

- I cycle, kayak, and go camping and it's easier to transport my gear

- I am a homeowner, and do the repairs and maintenance myself. It's hard to haul things like lumber and miter saw in the trunk of a civic.

- Taking tree trimmings and other wood mulch to a dump site

- When buying new furniture, I can move it myself instead of renting/borrowing a truck

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by toomuchtodo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:34AM (#18672530)
I used to own a large pickup truck. Traded in as part of my Tesla Model S purchase. Slapped a hitch on the Model S (2500 lb towing capacity) and I can do everything I did before with my pickup with my electric car (arguably easier with a lower platform for loading and unloading, and my trailer has a higher load limit than my pickup truck bed did).

Unless you’re hauling thousand of pounds behind that truck every day (above smaller vehicle tow limits, which is a legitimate use case if you're someone who is a shipper/transporter or contractor with a heavy trailer of some sort), it’s a waste, but to each their own.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by squish78 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:38AM (#18672557)
That seems like a reasonable alternative, but I like to also do maintenance on my own vehicle and have been working on combustion engines my whole life.

I supposed it is as unnecessary as anything in life, no more or less so than a Tesla, Civic, motorcycle, or scooter

Edit: I will concede that a mining dump truck would be unnecessary, in response to the parent comment

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by cronix on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:11AM (#18672790)
If you really enjoy doing maintenance, don't get a Tesla. The main thing you'd really be doing is changing tires every 40k or so, and eventually the battery pack. They are tremendously simple compared to a combustion engine. No spark plugs, no oil or filters to change, no oxygen sensors to go bad, no air filters, no fuel pumps or timing belts, etc. You'd be quite bored.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by squish78 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:18AM (#18672842)
You're preaching to choir. I think they are beautiful cars, but for other people. I've never paid over 10k for a vehicle, and I've never paid a mechanic. I only see a vehicle as a tool and Tesla is just another impractical status symbol but I absolutely admire the technology
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by toomuchtodo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:24AM (#18672896)
> I only see a vehicle as a tool and Tesla is just another impractical status symbol but I absolutely admire the technology

We see things differently. To me, it is the ultimate tool: efficient, reliable, the safest vehicle I can put my family in, and saves me time in the lack of fueling and maintenance required. I have no problem paying for nice tools. It's a sexy car, no doubt! But to me, that is far down the requirements list.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by squish78 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:37AM (#18673013)
I don't disagree with your points, but paying >$40k for a vehicle is an impossibility for most people. A working class shmuck like me can't prioritize luxury
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by toomuchtodo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:52AM (#18673177)
> but paying >$40k for a vehicle is an impossibility for most people.

I agree. I paid more than I would for a car so others in the future can pay less.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by cronix on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:45AM (#18673105)
That is true its more expensive up front, but they also last a lot longer than an ICE car and the gas/maintenance savings add quite a bit to that: https://electrek.co/2018/07/17/tesla-model-s-holds-up-400000...
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by briffle on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:27AM (#18673533)
That works great for small utility trailers, but not many tall cargo trailers or RV trailers can work that way. Some might be under the weight limits, barely, but when you factor in the wind resistance, and the shorter wheelbase of a sports car, it could be very dangerous.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by toomuchtodo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:38AM (#18673644)
My comment covers that. If you’re hauling large trailers daily, a pickup truck is for you. I would not haul a horse trailer with my S, but a flatbed trailer with various reasonable loads is fine (generators, a golf cart, lawn equipment, etc).
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by sentenza on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:52AM (#18673174)
Given the use case you describe, a Citroën Jumpy would probably be the most sensible car:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citro%C3%ABn_Jumpy

If you want a car that looks slightly better and costs a bit more, you could go with a VW T6:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_Transporter_(T6)

Here in Europe, most people with your usage pattern would actually just buy a station wagon and hitch a trailer to it when needed:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opel_Insignia#/media/File:Opel...

There are even rooftop containers for kayaks and specific cycle holders for the rear of the car so that you can go camping with a typical European station wagon without having to use a trailer.

I'm not trying to complain about the choices you made, but rather trying to emphasize the point of the article. Pickup trucks are more of a cultural phenomenon than a practical necessity. If the emission standards are raised, other solutions will appear without much/any loss in convenience.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by wafflesraccoon on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:04PM (#18673875)
I'd argue a pickup truck does everything described better than the three vehicles you posted. Most people only have one vehicle and a pickup is simply a great jack of all trades.

I 100% agree that pickups are a American cultural icon (just look at the ads, they drip nationalism) but it is hard to argue that they are not practical.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by sentenza on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:59PM (#18674435)
Pickup trucks indeed have their advantages over the vehicles I listed. However, I would disagree somewhat regarding where the advantages are.

I'd say that the vehicles I listed and pickup trucks manage fairly equally in the above transport categories (tools, furniture, kayak, bike). The way to go about it is just different.

But: Pickup trucks outclass all the vehicles I listed as soon as you leave the tarmac. Here in Germany, many people in rural areas who would own a pickup truck in the US also own a "family tractor" for working in the woods or in other off-road locations.

Then again: The vehicles I listed will always be faster on the Autobahn than a pickup truck. I regularly see people in station wagons go 160km/h and above for prolonged distances on the A3 at night.

In the end, I find it extremely fascinating how a different regulatory environment has bred different 'species' of utility vehicles on both sides of the Atlantic.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by squish78 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:37PM (#18674787)
The differences are indeed fascinating. The first vehicle you listed would never be owned by a private individual unless they used it for a business. It seems like the inverse is true with non-commercial pickup trucks in Europe
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by assblaster on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:57AM (#18672309)
Your straw man is not relevant.

You are asking people to purchase two vehicles for themselves: one high efficiency commuter and one utility vehicle.

Why do people in Texas commute with a pickup? Because they don't want to buy a sedan in addition, and I don't blame them. If you look at liberal California, you'll see tons of Subaru AWD light SUV/crossovers. Why don't Californians just bike everywhere to save on gas? Are you going to spite them because they want a vehicle that does everything they need?

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by adrianN on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:33AM (#18672519)
You don't have to buy a utility vehicle if you only use it once a month. Renting is both cheaper and better for the environment. Where I live many people don't own a car at all and rent one when they need it. For example I needed a car twice in the last three years.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by abakker on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:27AM (#18673537)
My experience has been that even all in, renting a truck once a month is not really that much cheaper, since buying a truck vs a car is not really a huge cost difference. Practically, getting to a place to rent a truck still sucks, and the whole process is still fairly inconvenient. It's nice that you don't need a car, that works with your lifestyle. OTOH, I don't commute, but my only vehicles is a large pickup truck because it is much more convenient for the things I do.

One size does not fit all, especially with expensive and utilitarian items like cars and trucks.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by wafflesraccoon on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:07PM (#18673909)
Not owning a car is unfortunately not a realistic reality living in all but a few US cities. Most American cities were built with the car in mind, without massive public infrastructure overall owing a car is basically a requirement.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by adrianN on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:53AM (#18678745)
That's unfortunately true, but not owning a big car certainly is possible.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:15AM (#18672403)
This.

Think of it as a three axis space with people capacity, indoor cargo space and outdoor cargo space on all three axis (I'm approximating here, there's more things than that people consider in a vehicle purchase but those are the big ones that determine which models you're considering).

Crew cab and extended cab trucks have a lot of all three of those things (even more if you toss on a cap) making them capable of checking all the "must have" boxes of many potential buyers. The people that don't need the outdoor space get crossovers. The people that need more indoor space or seating get three row SUVs and minivans. The people that need the same blend of indoor/outdoor/seating but less of it get midsize trucks.

The husband wants a driver's car with a manual and the wife wants a convertible with AWD and two rows of seating so they get a 4dr Jeep Wrangler (facepalm implied).

Of course most vehicles are at least partially a luxury purchase so people higher on the economic spectrum will purchase more capacity than they "need" (three row SUV for two kids, 3/4-ton truck to tow a pop up camper).

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by ensiferum on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:31AM (#18672511)
And these people really need big ass trucks.. to haul exactly what? I bet the great majority of people really don't need it for work or anything.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:41AM (#18672573)
People don't "need" it in the sense that they need food or water but they "need" it to conform to social norms. It's a class/status thing.

How hard you work your vehicles is inversely correlated with income (generally speaking, exceptions are in abundance when you speak in generalizations like this).

If you hang out with the HN type crowd then you'll rarely if ever see someone fill every seat in a car or use a pickup to its full capacity. We're generally rich enough to afford more vehicle than we "need" in every regard (pickup trucks to haul light loads, three rows of seating for families with <4 kids, high performance German driving machines for a commute that's mostly sitting in traffic, etc, etc). At the other end of the economic spectrum people shoehorn whatever vehicle is available to them into every role it needs to fill.

Every time I'm strapping material to the roof of one of my beater cars at home depot I'm immediately self aware that I am not acting the way people of my income level are expected to by other people of the same income level. Depending your income level pressing a less than ideal vehicle into service to fit all your needs is just not an option you let yourself seriously consider.

So yeah, the people driving newish vehicles are mostly rich enough to not "need" all the capability they have and it's generally not socially acceptable for these people to go all out using their vehicles.

Edit:

You can see this playing out in the comments.

Someone says they "need" a pickup to do something and gets responses like

"No you don't, people in India haul lumber on motorcycles"

or

"But people in France can tow their their boat with a subcompact car"

While that might be true the social norms of the US do not permit middle class and upper middle class people to use the piss out of their vehicles.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by pascalxus on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:58PM (#18677269)
is this a texas thing?

here in CA, i get the impression it's perfectly okay to load your car up quite fully. We put 5 people in an SUV without 3rd row seating on a regular basis without any kind of shame.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by EADGBE on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:57AM (#18672692)
Are common people not allowed to do utilitarian things with their privately-owned vehicles?

How else am I going to build a retaining wall, lawn maintenance, be the volunteer dance dad in the parade, pick up some building supplies for weekend projects, all while fitting three oversized safety-regulated car seats?

Come on, this statement is close-minded.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by Sharlin on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:23AM (#18672883)
Pickup trucks are almost unheard of outside the US, except in the countryside. SUVs are much rarer as well. Somehow people get by.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by donaltroddyn on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:28AM (#18673546)
In Ireland, pickups are fairly uncommon (probably because of the weather), but 4x4s like Land Cruisers, Patrols, Defenders, Discoveries, etc are really common.

The only category we don't have is what Americans call light trucks.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by Marsymars on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:30AM (#18672497)
Yes, big pickups get better fuel economy than big pickups from a decade ago, but the entire compact pickup market has been eliminated in North America.

I inherited my first pickup (a Nissan Hardbody), a couple decades ago from my father, who'd used it for years for beekeeping work, and the F-150 still doesn't match it for fuel economy.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by squish78 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:48AM (#18672622)
Now I want to know more about your beekeeping father
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by paganel on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:39AM (#18671867)
To be fair the CAFE standards have severely limited the choice of small trucks the US consumer can buy, but I agree that they have nothing to do with the Obama mandate as they are by now almost 40 years old, just with fuel economy standards in general.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by Sharlin on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:31AM (#18672962)
The infatuation of Americans with bigger and bigger vehicles is one of the things that is just bizarre from an outside point of view.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by supertrope on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:24PM (#18677666)
In the United States bigger is better.

A big car fits more people and cargo. They're safer in a crash (if you ignore single vehicle accidents and especially rollovers). Finally it's a status symbol: bigger generally means more impressive and expensive. Americans don't share their salaries and directly bragging is faux pas, but we tend to signal social-economic status through property.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by tertius on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:06AM (#18673321)
Cheap gas.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by pif on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:01PM (#18673851)
> They all have more power than ever.

Modern engines have a lot of power, when you are at full regime. Getting to full regime is what emission control directives have made more and more painful during last decades.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by gerbilly on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:46PM (#18674309)
Why not convert tractor trailers into pickups?

I bet they would sell really well.

You know the bigger the better, right?

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by travisporter on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:57AM (#18672306)
Is there a way to remain safe driving in these places besides also buying a large heavy vehicle? I despise gas guzzlers but my sedan may not survive an accident.
Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by Retric on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:07AM (#18672355)
Vehicle size has minimal impact on collision safty. People regularly survive collisions with Semi Trucks for example.

Also those SUV’s often look huge, but a Honda Accord weighs 2/3 as much as a Chevy Suburban before adding passengers. Weight reduces acceleration and fuel economy so they use body styles that look huge while being mostly hollow.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by rootusrootus on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:53AM (#18672655)
I'm reaching back a ways to my college days, but as I remember, two objects can have masses 2x apart (e.g. 3500 pound car, 7000 pound truck) and for all practical purposes it doesn't really change the collision dynamics much. Something about velocity squared, as I recall.

So ... buy a Subaru Forester, I guess. Or another CUV. Taller bumper so you don't get run over by a pickup, but still a smallish vehicle.

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:14AM (#18673415)
KE=0.5MV^2

Vehicle and cargo (you) damage is more strongly related to force than kinetic energy. You can be going 150mph and stop just fine by using the brakes to convert that kinetic energy into thermal energy. Using a concrete barrier and the vehicle to dissipate that force throughout the structure of the vehicle would work as well as far as getting rid of the kinetic energy but will probably have a less desirable outcome for the contents of the vehicle. Same energy in both cases, way different forces involved. It's like how a sledgehammer hits with more force the more rigid the thing you're hitting is.

Also it's not the acceleration that kills you[1], it's the bouncing off things in the cabin that kills you.

[1]http://www.ejectionsite.com/stapp.htm (8th to last paragraph)

Re:The Oil Industry’s Covert Campaign to Rewrite American Ca... by jiveturkey on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:18AM (#18672428)
honestly, who cares if your car survives? will you survive? if you have a car made within the last 20 years, most likely yes.