News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: My experience with karma average staring me in t... by radu_floricica on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @05:31PM (#1866613)
I'd say the single most significant thing pg could do for the karma system is to weight votes by the total number of votes in the story.

Right now it is way easier to get karma in animate, controversial topics rather then in insightful, complex discussions.

I think I understand why he hesitates: weighting removes the simplicity of one vote - one point. But if karma is supposed to overcome blind popularity, I think it's necessary.

Re:Tell HN: My experience with karma average staring me in t... by sz on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @07:43PM (#1866967)
Easy karma fraud.
Re:Tell HN: My experience with karma average staring me in t... by radu_floricica on Thursday November 04, 2010 @06:56PM (#1871173)
Not if weighting is below 1.0, i.e. threads with lots of comments get less karma, but sparse threads get close to 1.0.
Re:Tell HN: My experience with karma average staring me in t... by sz on Thursday November 04, 2010 @07:50PM (#1871360)
Something like

  karma per vote = #comments / #votes
Okay, actually that sounds reasonable.
Re:Tell HN: My experience with karma average staring me in t... by sz on Friday November 05, 2010 @04:14PM (#1874701)
Hah wait that's not actually what you said, which still doesn't sound reasonable.

Also a better formula might be something closer to

  karma per vote = thread karma / total comment karma in thread
Re:Tell HN: My experience with karma average staring me in t... by sz on Thursday November 11, 2010 @01:55AM (#1893134)
Oh, and of course the average would have to be weighted by thread karma.

  average = total user karma / sum of thread karma over all threads commented in