Re:Google Engineering Management Mistakes
by gaius on Thursday November 04, 2010 @09:46AM
(#1868811)
Not if your annual targets have already been entered into SAP HR and the system won't let them be modified outside of the appraisal period, and required yes/no answers to them in the next appraisal period for it to do ranking calculations.
Basically if you have a formal appraisal process at all you're trapped in a machine.
Presumably when A gets cancelled, he comes by and says, "A just got cancelled" (or you tell him, depending on how news flows). "This was part of my plan for this cycle, how can we adjust the plan?" And then you discuss giving him proper credit for work on A until it was canceled, and then break down what his new priorities look like.
Or, "I just started work on D, how does this fit in the plan?" "Currently it doesn't, but lets get it in there".
There should be very few things that happen that would be so important that they'd be worth discussion in a promotion that you don't communicate about within a day or two of it first appearing on the radar (if not hours).
The last issue of a reorg is the one that is toughest to deal with. I would talk to their new manager, layout their plans, etc..., but there's no guarantee that the new manager will have the same philosophy.
Being a manager is hard work. And frankly, I'm largely done with people management. It's the hardest job I've ever had, bar none. But its important, and I think some of the problems noted in this article are things good management training can deal with.