Re:The Firefox Dilemma
by fimdomeio on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @05:45AM
(#18654433)
Crazy idea. what would happen if firefox would also become chromium based? You would now have a browser as fast as chrome but with better privacy features that chrome will never compete against.
If chromium is open source other companies could share the control over code right?
I suspect this is a terrible idea but still trying to find out why.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
You'd lose out on the WebRender and all the other Quantum/Servo-related improvements, their influence over web standards, their extended extension APIs and pretty much all respect they've built up over the years.
Having different rendering engines means that at least theoretically the W3C are in control of web standards; having only one rendering engine, Chromium, means the W3C is irrelevant and the standard is "what Chomium does".
Firefox as it is now is much faster than Chrome already.
Not even close. I wrote a comment [0] with my examples recently. I like FF (though besides Containers, most reasons boil down to "it's not Chrome"), but fast is a word I'd only use in comparison to IE/Edge.
I know it's a tempting thought. Mozilla has certainly evaluated (and discarded) this possibility – as you mention, it's not a good idea.
I posted a few reasons for this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18655028
Also
> If chromium is open source other companies could share the control over code right?
The sole governing body for Chromium is Google. Other companies get exactly as much control as Google decides.
That's the opposite of, say, the Linux Kernel or Rust. It is my understanding that Firefox is also heading in the same direction as these, i.e. towards shared control by all stakeholders.