Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem
by thousandautumns on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @09:46AM
(#18655572)
I believe this is related to another principle in Economics called Goodhart's Law, which essentially states that as soon as something becomes a metric for measuring performance, it ceases to be a valid measure of actual performance. Essentially using something as a performance metric creates the incentive to game the system, inflate their values, and generally divorce the metric from the phenomenon it's trying to measure.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem
by lordnacho on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @03:57AM
(#18654026)
IMO the deeper history in Lucas Critique is the Problem of Induction.
"XYZ has always worked in the past" doesn't work. Imagine doing machine learning on this problem that Bird has. It could easily suggest that you should up the fees to get more scooter finders, rather than that you need to change the incentives.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem
by elvinyung on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @02:45AM
(#18653776)
Lucas critique is predated by Campbell's law and Goodhart's law.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem
by base698 on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @10:02AM
(#18655707)
This was described in "The Wire" as juking the stats: https://youtu.be/_ogxZxu6cjM
EDIT: To clarify -- I'm not an economist, it's just something I read about in my spare time. I'm sure that the Lucas critique was pre-dated by other ideas (it's far too obvious to be entirely novel), and that there's a much deeper analysis that I wasn't aware of.