News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by jaimehrubiks on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @02:23AM (#18653708)
This is, indeed, a very hard problem to solve. The only option I see is banning somehow by law/agreement, and taking legal actions to people who 'steal' them. But in that case they would just stack them outside the house...

You could ban people who charge bikes to use them (it is as weird as if an uber driver couldn't use uber as a passenger).

Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by solatic on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @02:42AM (#18653769)
> a very hard problem to solve

Is it? Honest chargers who go out to the boonies to recover truly hard-to-recover scooters will pick up scooters which turn red from all over the place. Dishonest chargers who kidnap scooters will have scooters who all turned red suspiciously in one place (the charger's home).

Developing an algorithm to find the dishonest players should be relatively straightforward, and after dishonest players are found, they should be banned.

Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by Normal_gaussian on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @02:56AM (#18653822)
Yes, this seems largely trivial for a moderate sized company.

Will it be perfect? No. Will it be effective? Yes. Will it make a great HN blog post? Absolutely

Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by michaelt on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @04:42AM (#18654173)

  Dishonest chargers who kidnap scooters will have scooters
  who all turned red suspiciously in one place (the
  charger's home).
...until the dishonest chargers figure out they can easily block the GPS signal with a few cents of tinfoil when they grab the scooter off the street.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by SamReidHughes on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @04:53AM (#18654217)
You can catch that too.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by michaelt on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @05:18AM (#18654315)
How will you robustly tell apart vandals from dishonest chargers, when the latter are incentivised to emulate the former?
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by ApolloFortyNine on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @11:24AM (#18656375)
Well you just ban them. You might catch some innocents but that's their right. If someone has a habit of turning in a whole bunch of scooters that didn't have GPS available for X days before, ban them. A legitimate charger should have a certain percentage of scooters where the GPS was available up until charging (1-2 day turn around I'm guessing, or there's some fundamental flaw with the charging system), so I'm sure there's an algorithm that can remove a majority of the abusers with minimal casualties.

You can never solve gaming the system entirely, the goal is just to make it harder than it's worth, and hopefully the abusers move to some other scheme.

Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by michaelt on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @12:49PM (#18657124)

  If someone has a habit of turning in a whole
  bunch of scooters that didn't have GPS
  available for X days before, ban them.
You've just banned your best guy, Wader Wayne, the only guy in the city who was retrieving scooters that vandals had chucked in the river.

Now he's complaining on your employees' subreddit everyone said he was doing a great job and his numbers were really good, that no-one else should invest in equipment to do the same work, and that you've ruined Christmas for his family by cutting off their only source of income. The Guardian is going to interview him for their article on job insecurity in the gig economy.

Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by solatic on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @04:19PM (#18658989)
All of these parameters are tunable. You don't have to get rid of 90% of the dishonest catchers, if even 50-70% will make a big difference. Your argument would have more merit if the majority of unrecoverable scooters were due to vandalism, but the facts bear out that the vast majority are due to hoarding.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by SamReidHughes on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @05:36AM (#18654384)
From the GPS signal being blocked some time before they charge the scooters.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by michaelt on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @08:35AM (#18655179)
You think vandals never chuck scooters places they can't get GPS signals, like in rivers or metal dumpsters?
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by SamReidHughes on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @08:45AM (#18655231)
You use statistics.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by ec109685 on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @02:37AM (#18653752)
These hoarders display obviously anomalous behavior. Overtime, Bird will be able to weed out this fraud.
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by CaptainZapp on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @04:28AM (#18654126)
The only option I see is banning somehow by law/agreement, and taking legal actions to people who 'steal' them.

There's something really funny about the libertarian mindset here:

  - Screw regulations! Disrupt! Use public property for private gain, but then
  - Let the hammer of the law crash down and the state deal with those scundrels if there are unintended consequences
Theres' a smidgeon of hypocrisy here, don't you think?
Re:San Diego's Bird Scooter Hoarding Problem by dnautics on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @11:56AM (#18656661)
The libertarian mindset is pretty clear: There should be a small number of regulations, with a specific scope (e.g. protecting against physical harm and protecting property), which are clearly enumerated so that anyone, across most levels of education, can easily and reasonably determine if the regulation is fair or not.