Re:Hook on PG&E Tower Eyed as Cause of Deadly Camp Fire
by chongli on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:44PM
(#18653207)
Your analogy doesn't quite fit. A wildfire zone with large amounts of flammable dry vegetation isn't analogous to an ordinary house. It's more like a house with a gas leak that's been left alone long enough for the entire building to fill up with natural gas.
Now, in that situation, does it matter whether your house gets struck by lightning or your neighbour's cigarette lighter happens to set it off near a cracked window? Assuming your neighbour is miraculously unhurt, the answer is no.
Re:Hook on PG&E Tower Eyed as Cause of Deadly Camp Fire
by oasisbob on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @12:46PM
(#18657093)
Drive onto ranch land with a hot exhaust system, pull off the road into tall grass, start a 200 acre grass fire, and try to use that line of reasoning with a with a straight face.
Re:Hook on PG&E Tower Eyed as Cause of Deadly Camp Fire
by jfoutz on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:53PM
(#18652780)
So, fuck pg&e. I’m not a fan.
That said, this isn’t quite burned down a house, which they should absolutely be on the hook for, this is the whole city burned down.
There is sort of a structural responsibility to limit blast radius of bad actors that also failed.
Re:Hook on PG&E Tower Eyed as Cause of Deadly Camp Fire
by adrianmonk on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:00PM
(#18652799)
If I improperly stored tons of firewood right against my house, and someone caught the firewood in fire, and then my house burned down, I think I'd share some of the blame. Some blame would have to go on the other person too.
Would it make a difference if that person had a history of disobeying safety rules, had been warned a number of times, and had caused significant damage in the past?
The fact that some subset of fires can't be prevented doesn't mean we should throw up our hands and never try to prevent any fires. When somebody causes one we should investigate and take appropriate action.