Innovation -- on a scale untouchable by cheaper, younger, hungrier competitors -- is one way to differentiate. Another is to find a niche that cares about (and will pay for) the best of the best. But those niches shrink every year as the Great Unwashed move up the learning curve.
As it is, it kind of reminds me of a slightly cruder version of the sites I was building in my early teens for £4 per hour back at the beginning of the last decade. I'm amazed they turned down all the extra cash...
My experience is that fussiness is inversely proportionate to price sensitivity. Now if a prospect tries to dicker over hundreds or tell me they "have a nephew who does this kind of stuff," I end the conversation as quickly as possible.
[edit: I say this as someone who, in the early days of the web, was one of those kids making websites by hand or with pagemill for $2000 a pop. I don't begrudge anyone doing this today.]
I agree about customers that try to use the boss' nephew as a bargaining chip generally being the ones that also expect the website to rapidly delivered and perfect, but there's plenty of money to be made from small businesses that don't need or want anything complicated.
The other moral of the story for me is that I should avoid markets where a 10 year old can easily be successful. I mean if the client cannot make a difference between your work and the work of a 10 year old, then you may not be in the good market. Here in Hungary 'small scale web development' (website creation for small firms) is in the hands of young guys (although not 10 year olds, more like 20) working for very low amount of money. I avoid that market like plague. Also I don't want to be 'the IT guy' for a small non-tech firm, which is very similar.
"He dashed off a check for $2,000" My god, how incredibly happy a 20 year old average PHP developer in Hungary would be for having $2,000 for the mentioned site...