News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer?

I have to evaluate a tender offer for private stock from a previous employer with a deadline coming up. I have some updated financial statements but have no idea if this is fair or not. On the one hand, it would be smart to diversify since it’s decent sum of money in the “SF house money” size. On the other hand, it would suck if the shares were actually worth much more and sold prematurely.
( 8 comments | 13 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by ralph84 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:01PM (#18638044)
Sell half. Keeps you in the game if there’s big upside while getting some cash now if there’s not.
Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by wufufufu on Sunday December 09, 2018 @12:23PM (#18641989)
I'm not disagreeing, but what's your background/reasoning for this advice, specifically the "50%" part?
Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by khurram on Sunday December 09, 2018 @10:37PM (#18644996)
When I worked in markets I would often get asked questions in the form of: should I short X? Should I trade X currency now or later?

More specifically many questioned whether they should buy GBP/USD the day before brexit or the day after. The only good advice is to buy 50% the day before and 50% the day after, that way you are wrong both times.

Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by toomuchtodo on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:54PM (#18642516)
It’s a common practice as it relates to speculative investments that have seen significant gains but you’re unsure of future value. Selling half locks in some gains (de-risking) while still preserving possible future upside (the half you don’t sell).
Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by pbiggar on Saturday December 08, 2018 @09:46PM (#18638934)
This is gonna be pretty hard to figure out. I'd recommend you take it to someone knowledgable - a startup accountant or lawyer perhaps; they can give you comparables. For the kind of money you're talking about you should definitely have a lawyer looking over the docs.

I tried writing out some general advice, but there's so many possible scenarios: is the company hot, is growth flat, is it trying to sell to someone (PE firm or later stage investor), why are they even buying your stock?

I agree with ralph84 that selling some smaller number keeps you in the game and also let's you cash out - founders and early employees regularly do this, and they are big believers in future upside. Also remember that even if the stock goes up in the future, you should price in the cost of having that money now (everything from the appreciation of a house you may buy, to factoring in expected value).

Main advice: get a lawyer. If you're looking for someone to talk through the options informally, my email is in my profile.

Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by pleinair7 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @07:26PM (#18638365)
One common approach for valuation is to use comparable companies as a benchmark. This is where you take a similar company's financial statements and compare the relative valuation. The first step is to identify similar companies and do a search for their valuations. Once you have similar companies, you can use ratio like price/earnings to compare them. good luck.
Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by nicholas73 on Sunday December 09, 2018 @07:23AM (#18640540)
More likely the company at this stage is evaluated on earnings growth, not absolute earnings. Or more nebulous, $/user. But it's a way to mentally check whether the valuation is reasonable. Will the earnings growth grow into a stable earnings fit for its market cap? A mature best of breed company (S&P average) gets something like 22 P/E right now, but historically that fluctuates as well based on earnings outlook and interest rates (which are still historically low).

The last point on interest rates is overlooked by casual investors. Interest rates drive valuation, because the risk-free Treasuries rate is the ultimate comparable to other investments. Not only does it cause the P/E of mature companies to blow up as people chase yield, it forces hot money to chase earnings growth as prospective returns get miniscule. It also gives funds massive borrowing power.

Basically, consider the risk of the whole thing blowing up even if the company does not.

The last line sounds scary, and it could be, and if you don't know it's the thing to really consider. Risk versus reward. Selling half seems like a brainless way to make a decision, but the benefit of this is that it actually lets you make a decision (you win psychologically both ways).

Companies do not do stock tenders all that often and it could be a good sign. But it also happens that companies buy during good times when cash is flush.

Re:Ask HN: How do you evaluate a stock tender offer? by source99 on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:54PM (#18652497)
Find a middle ground that won’t let you regret your decision. I tried this once and felt pretty good about the results.